Lowest price from $10 per page Start saving now →
Financial Reporting

Ratio Analysis for Acquisition Appraisal

UGB394 International Financial Reporting: Presentation, Financial Statements and Client Advice

Module and Assessment Context

University of Sunderland runs UGB394 International Financial Reporting at Level 6 inside the BA (Hons) Accounting and Financial Management top up, and the module carries a single assessment weighted at 100 per cent of the module mark. Assessment for UGB394 International Financial Reporting at the University of Sunderland takes the form of one coursework submission built from three linked questions, where a PowerPoint presentation to a board, a set of published financial statements and two pieces of written client advice sit inside the same document. Delivery sits within the Faculty of Business, Law and Tourism across the Sunderland campuses and partner centres, and the module runs over 300 learning hours against 30 credits at Year 3. Students answer all three questions, and the brief states plainly that only submissions lodged through Canvas will be marked. The mix of formats is deliberate, since the module tests numerical preparation, interpretive judgement and professional communication in one artefact.

Assessment Snapshot

Institution and faculty University of Sunderland, Faculty of Business, Law and Tourism
Module code and title UGB394 International Financial Reporting
Programme and level BA (Hons) Accounting and Financial Management top up, Level 6, Year 3
Credit and learning hours 30 credits, 300 learning hours
Assessment type Individual coursework, single assessment, three compulsory questions
Weight 100 per cent of the module mark
Total marks 100 marks, being 50 for Question 1, 32 for Question 2 and 18 for Question 3
Question 1 length 1,800 words, delivered as no more than 12 content slides plus a welcome slide and a questions slide, with the spoken commentary written in Word after each slide
Question 2 length No word limit, since the answer is a statement of profit or loss, a statement of financial position and supporting notes
Question 3 length Approximately 750 words for part A and a maximum of 450 words for part B
Referencing Harvard, following Cite Them Right, with in text citations in every written answer
Submission Canvas only, with a Turnitin originality report where the centre supports it
Front cover Name, student registration number, word count excluding references, bibliography and appendices, plus the student misconduct declaration on the official cover sheet

Assessment Task

Answer all three questions. Question 1 requires a board presentation built from a supplied ratio table for two acquisition targets. Question 2 requires the preparation for publication of a statement of profit or loss and a statement of financial position from a trial balance with eight year end adjustments. Question 3 requires two pieces of written advice, one on the capitalisation of a machine under IAS 16 and one on the capitalisation of development expenditure under IAS 38.

Question 1: Acquisition Appraisal Presentation, 50 Marks

Tangled Plc is a wholesale distributor of security solutions for large industrial complexes. The company is weighing investment in either Rapunzel Ltd or Flynn Secure Ltd, and the assistant to the Finance Director has prepared the following ratios for the year ended 31 December 2024.

Ratio Rapunzel Ltd Flynn Secure Ltd
Current ratio 1.1 4.0
Acid test ratio 0.80 1.0
Accounts receivable days 50 30
Inventory turnover, times 6.0 12.80
Accounts payable days 75 30
Total debt to total assets 40 per cent 80 per cent
Gross profit percentage 24.6 per cent 12.5 per cent
Operating profit percentage 10 per cent 5 per cent
Return on capital employed 16 per cent 4 per cent
Gearing 20 per cent 75 per cent
Interest cover, times 2 5
Dividends in pence 7.20 1.20

Prepare a PowerPoint presentation to the Board of Directors of Tangled Plc that analyses the performance of both companies and recommends which investment offers the better opportunity. Cover the performance areas the supplied data allows, and comment on any further information the board should obtain before committing. Cap the deck at 12 content slides plus one welcome slide and one slide for additional questions. Copy every slide into a Microsoft Word document and write the spoken commentary you would deliver directly beneath each slide, since the deck itself will not be presented aloud and the Word document carries the marks. Write to 1,800 words.

Question 2: Preparation of Published Financial Statements, 32 Marks

Quantum Systems Ltd is the European distributor of specialised AI powered medical diagnostic equipment. The Finance Director has asked for the accounts for the year ended 30 April 2025, ready for publication on Monday. A trial balance has been supplied showing sales of 17,000,000, fixtures at cost of 1,500,000 and accumulated depreciation of 300,000, motor vehicles at cost of 1,200,000 and accumulated depreciation of 200,000, land of 4,000,000, goodwill of 1,500,000, debentures of 2,000,000, issued ordinary share capital of 300,000, issued preference share capital of 100,000, a share premium of 20,000, retained earnings of 1,900,000, inventory of 200,000, purchases of 9,500,000, trade receivables of 250,000, trade payables of 260,000, rent receivable of 400,000, cash at bank of 1,150,000, distribution costs of 230,000 and administrative expenses of 300,000, with the trial balance footing at 22,480,000 on both sides. All figures are in thousands.

  • An audit fee of 20,000 remains unrecorded.
  • Fixtures depreciate at 10 per cent straight line and vehicles at 25 per cent reducing balance.
  • Goodwill suffered an impairment of 550,000 in the year.
  • Income tax of 150,000 falls due.
  • Debenture interest at 10 per cent has not yet been paid.
  • Closing inventory was valued at 100,000 at the lower of cost and net realisable value.
  • Land was revalued upward by 450,000.
  • No vehicles were bought during the year, and one vehicle costing 10,000 with depreciation to date of 5,000 was sold, with the transaction already reflected in the trial balance.

Produce a statement of profit or loss worth 10 marks, notes to the statement of profit or loss worth 5 marks, a statement of financial position worth 14 marks and notes to the statement of financial position worth 3 marks.

Question 3: Client Advice, 18 Marks

Both parts must be answered to earn full marks. The scenario places you in a small accounting firm, advising clients on issues they have not met before.

  • Part A, 12 marks. A VAT registered client has bought a machine for a new production line, with production beginning on 1 July. The costs presented are basic cost of 300,000, a manufacturer discount of 120,000, VAT of 80,000, non recoverable import duties of 50,000, employment costs for construction staff over three months to 31 July of 30,000, and other overheads of 20,000 arising from a three day power cut and the resulting delay. Identify the cost of each line to be added and the total machine cost for 6 marks, then explain for each line why the amount is included or excluded for 6 marks, in a report of approximately 750 words.
  • Part B, 6 marks. Espresso Plc, incorporated in Singapore in 1998, has spent 2,800,000 this year developing a faster roasting technique for its Golden Tropic Roast, after writing off the first two years of research costs on previous advice. A further 1,000,000 is estimated as necessary to reach market, and the company intends to use the process exclusively. Write a concise email of no more than 450 words to Mr Mocha explaining the capitalisation criteria under IAS 38 and assess whether the 2,800,000 should be capitalised or expensed. Reference the written answers.

Requirements

Presentation, Structure and Word Control

  • Answer all three questions in one submitted document, with Question 1’s slides reproduced in Word and the commentary written beneath each slide rather than in a separate speaker note file.
  • Keep Question 1 to twelve content slides at most, plus the welcome slide and the additional questions slide, since a deck that runs long loses presentation marks before content is read.
  • Declare the word count on the front cover, excluding the reference list, bibliography and appendices, and keep Question 3 to 750 words and 450 words respectively.
  • Attach the student misconduct declaration on the official cover sheet, and print your tutor’s name clearly on the front.
  • Submit through Canvas as an individual assignment, with a Turnitin originality report where your centre supports it, since handwritten or hard copy submissions are treated as non submission.

Referencing and Evidence

  • Use Harvard style following Cite Them Right for every citation and every reference list entry.
  • Cite the accounting standards directly where the answer turns on a recognition rule, naming IAS 16 for property, plant and equipment and IAS 38 for intangible assets rather than paraphrasing them from a textbook.
  • Support the interpretive claims in Question 1 and Question 3 with academic and professional literature, not only with the supplied figures.

Academic Integrity and Artificial Intelligence

  • Declare any use of artificial intelligence on a separate attachment to the cover sheet.
  • Restrict AI use to brainstorming, since the brief permits idea generation and forbids submitting generated prose as your own.
  • Cite any AI generated content that survives into the submission.
  • Accept that the University’s policy on cheating, collusion and plagiarism applies to every part of the coursework.

Submission Structure

  1. Official cover sheet carrying your name, student registration number, tutor name, declared word count and the misconduct declaration.
  2. Separate AI use declaration attachment.
  3. Question 1, presentation slides with the spoken commentary beneath each slide.
  4. Question 2, statement of profit or loss, related notes, statement of financial position and related notes.
  5. Question 3 part A, the client report on machine cost.
  6. Question 3 part B, the email to Mr Mocha.
  7. Reference list in Harvard style following Cite Them Right.
  8. Appendices where working schedules support the numerical answers.

Marking Rubric

Question Level Allocation

Criterion Marks What the marker looks for
Profitability interpretation 10 Margins and return on capital employed read against each other, with the gap between gross and operating margin explained rather than described
Liquidity and working capital 10 Current and acid test ratios interpreted together, with the receivables and payables position tied to cash generation
Efficiency 10 Inventory turnover and receivable days connected to the operating cycle, with the consequence for funding stated
Gearing and solvency 8 Gearing and interest cover combined into a risk judgement, including the effect of the debt weight on covenant headroom
Recommendation and further information 7 A named target justified on evidence, with the missing information specified rather than requested in general terms
Presentation and referencing 5 Slide discipline, readable visuals, commentary that functions as speech, Harvard citations without error

The 50 mark split above reconstructs the criterion pattern for Question 1, since the released brief prints the total only. Question 2 marks are printed: 10 for the statement of profit or loss, 5 for its notes, 14 for the statement of financial position and 3 for its notes. Question 3 marks are printed as 6, 6 and 6.

University Generic Assessment Criteria, Undergraduate

Band Relevance and knowledge Analysis and argument Critical evaluation Presentation and literature
86 to 100 per cent Exemplary grasp of the material at Level 6, all outcomes fully satisfied Compelling evaluation and elegance of argument Distinctive independent position formed against theory and practice Flawless expression and format, critical appraisal of current literature
76 to 85 per cent Excellent and directly relevant coverage Good analysis, clear and orderly structure Coherent independent position begins to form Very good use of source material, minor lapses only
70 to 75 per cent High standard with clear articulation of the issues Analysis present with some originality Evaluation moves beyond description in most places Well written with acceptable format and a range of sources
60 to 69 per cent Relevant to the requirements, adequate knowledge of a fair range of material Some analytical treatment, prone to description in places A view starts to form, largely derivative Competently written, some literature used
50 to 59 per cent Basic understanding over a limited range of material Largely descriptive or narrative Uncritical conformity to a standard view Simple style with deficiencies in expression or format
40 to 49 per cent Some correlation with the assessment, with instances of irrelevance Basic argument supported mainly by assertion Little coherence, derivative throughout Limited use of sources, clarity achieved only in places
35 to 39 per cent Relevance intermittent, narrowed to the vaguest terms Heavy dependence on description and paraphrase Writer’s contribution rarely exceeds simplifying Numerous deficiencies, over reliance on tutor material
Below 35 per cent Insufficient evidence that the outcomes are met No coherent argument No independent position formed Weak in several or all indicators

Bands and descriptor logic follow the University of Sunderland Generic Assessment Criteria for undergraduate bachelor’s degrees, which the published handbook sets at 86 to 100, 76 to 85, 70 to 75, 60 to 69, 50 to 59, 40 to 49, 35 to 39, 30 to 34, 15 to 29 and 0 to 14 per cent. Programmes approved from 2020-21 onward use the revised criteria, so confirm which version your programme falls under.

Assumptions and Verification Notes

Four points need stating plainly. Verified against mirrored copies of the released brief: the 100 per cent weighting, the three compulsory questions, the 1,800 word and 450 word ceilings, the twelve slide cap, the eight year end adjustments, the printed mark splits for Questions 2 and 3, the Canvas only submission rule and the AI declaration requirement. Rotating between offerings: the question content itself, since one version of this brief uses Helios Ltd and River Ltd inside a written report to Apollo Plc with a different mark split of 11, 5, 14 and 4 for Question 2, and an earlier version uses Pixie Plc for the trial balance question. Adopt the company names printed in your own brief, because a presentation built on Tangled Plc while your cohort was issued Apollo Plc will read as recycled work. Unresolved: the sixth cost line in Question 3 part A, since the abstracted copy of the brief truncates the table after the power cut overheads and prints a further figure without its label, so read the full table from Canvas. Named inconsistently: the 2024/25 module handbook lists Philip Dodds as module leader while the university staff profile for the accounting group lists Kinga Lovell against the same module code, so address correspondence to whoever is named in your current Canvas module site.

Academic Integrity

Sunderland permits artificial intelligence for idea generation and requires declaration of that use, which places the burden on the student to keep a record of prompts and to mark any generated text that survives into the submission. Copying a circulated answer carries a second risk here, because the question content rotates and a deck written for Rapunzel and Flynn will not match a cohort issued Helios and River. Question 2 is the section where contract cheating is easiest to detect, since a prepared answer will miss the interaction between the vehicle disposal and the reducing balance charge, and markers see that error repeatedly in copied work. Group discussion of the ratio table is collusion unless the brief authorises it, and this brief does not. Keep working schedules in an appendix so that a marker can trace each adjustment, and retain your draft versions in case authorship is queried.

References and Learning Materials

Amel-Zadeh, A., Glaum, M. and Sellhorn, T. (2023) ‘Empirical goodwill research: insights, issues, and implications for standard setting and future research’, European Accounting Review, 32(2), pp. 415-446. doi:10.1080/09638180.2021.1983854

Dargenidou, C., Jackson, R.H.G., Tsalavoutas, I. and Tsoligkas, F. (2021) ‘Capitalisation of R&D and the informativeness of stock prices: pre- and post-IFRS evidence’, The British Accounting Review, 53(4), 100998. doi:10.1016/j.bar.2021.100998

Han, H., Tang, J.J. and Tang, Q. (2021) ‘Goodwill impairment, securities analysts, and information transparency’, European Accounting Review, 30(4), pp. 767-799. doi:10.1080/09638180.2020.1791725

Hellman, N. and Hjelström, T. (2023) ‘The goodwill impairment test under IFRS: objective, effectiveness and alternative approaches’, Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, 52, 100558. doi:10.1016/j.intaccaudtax.2023.100558

International Accounting Standards Board (2023) IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment. London: IFRS Foundation. Available at: https://www.ifrs.org/issued-standards/list-of-standards/ias-16-property-plant-and-equipment/

International Accounting Standards Board (2023) IAS 38 Intangible Assets. London: IFRS Foundation. Available at: https://www.ifrs.org/issued-standards/list-of-standards/ias-38-intangible-assets/

Mazzi, F., Slack, R., Tsalavoutas, I. and Tsoligkas, F. (2022) ‘Exploring investor views on accounting for R&D costs under IAS 38’, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 41(2), 106944. doi:10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2022.106944

Pears, R. and Shields, G. (2022) Cite Them Right: The Essential Referencing Guide. 13th ed. London: Bloomsbury Academic. Prescribed referencing guide for Harvard style at Sunderland.

Note on style: Sunderland prescribes Harvard following Cite Them Right for this programme, not APA and not AGLC. In text citations take the form (Mazzi et al., 2022, p. 8) with page numbers added for direct quotation, and et al. is used from four authors onward.

Sample Answer: Reading the Ratio Table Like a Board Member

Rapunzel Ltd and Flynn Secure Ltd diverge on almost every dimension, and the divergence itself is the finding a board needs. Rapunzel earns 24.6 per cent gross margin against 12.5 per cent for Flynn, converts that into a 10 per cent operating margin against 5 per cent, and returns 16 per cent on capital employed against 4 per cent, which together mark it as the more profitable business. Working capital tells the opposite story, since Rapunzel runs a current ratio of 1.1 with an acid test of 0.80, holds receivables for 50 days and pays suppliers over 75 days, while Flynn holds a 4.0 current ratio and turns inventory 12.8 times a year. Gearing completes the picture, because Flynn carries 80 per cent of total assets in debt but covers interest five times, whereas Rapunzel gears at 20 per cent and covers interest only twice. A recommendation that stops at profitability therefore misses the risk that makes the acquisition decision difficult. Evidence on goodwill impairment, securities analysts, and information transparency suggests that acquiring firms under pressure to meet earnings expectations defer impairment recognition, so the presenter should also ask how much of Flynn’s asset base rests on goodwill that has not yet been tested (Han, Tang and Tang, 2021). Slide economy matters here, since twelve slides covering four performance areas plus a recommendation leaves two slides for the missing information and one for the decision itself, and a deck that spends five slides on profitability will not reach the recommendation.

Sample Answer: Capitalising the Machine and Advising on Development Costs

A machine is carried at cost under IAS 16, and cost means the expenditure necessary to bring the asset to the location and condition for its intended use, which settles most of the line items without argument. The basic cost of 300,000 enters the total, and the manufacturer discount of 120,000 is deducted because a discount reduces the consideration paid. VAT of 80,000 is excluded where the client can recover it as a VAT registered trader, and non recoverable import duties of 50,000 are included because the client cannot reclaim them. Employment costs of 30,000 for construction staff run to 31 July while production begins on 1 July, so a portion relates to testing and commissioning rather than to getting the asset ready, which makes the split the marks earning judgement in the answer. The 20,000 of overhead arising from a three day power cut and the resulting delay is excluded, since abnormal costs do not belong in cost. Development expenditure poses a harder question, because IAS 38 requires all research expenditure to be expensed and permits capitalisation only once technical feasibility, intention, ability, probable economic benefit, resource adequacy and reliable measurement are all demonstrated. Investor evidence on investor views on accounting for R&D costs under IAS 38 records that analysts treat the six criteria as open to managerial interpretation and read rising capitalisation ratios as a possible sign of earnings management, which gives the email its cautionary edge (Mazzi et al., 2022). Espresso Plc wrote off two years of research costs, intends exclusive use of the process, and still needs 1,000,000 to reach market, so the feasibility and resource criteria are the ones to test in 450 words rather than the whole framework.

Where Impairment Testing Drives the Marks

The goodwill adjustment in Question 2 looks mechanical and is not, since a 550,000 impairment charge cuts straight into operating profit and then into retained earnings, and a student who records it as an intangible asset reduction without touching profit loses marks in two places. Reviewing the empirical evidence on empirical goodwill research shows that goodwill carrying amounts track the underlying economics of the combination while also responding to managerial incentives and the institutional setting, which is precisely why the examiner supplies an impairment figure rather than asking students to estimate one (Amel-Zadeh, Glaum and Sellhorn, 2023). Alternative impairment models matter for the written commentary, and analysis of the goodwill impairment test under IFRS argues that a pre-acquisition headroom model produces more effective impairment than the current standard, which gives a defensible sentence about limits in the standard rather than an unsupported criticism (Hellman and Hjelström, 2023). Four adjustment traps account for most lost marks in this question:

  1. Depreciating the sold vehicle for a full year, when the disposal is already reflected in the trial balance and only the current year charge on remaining vehicles is outstanding.
  2. Applying straight line depreciation to vehicles, when the brief specifies 25 per cent reducing balance.
  3. Omitting accrued debenture interest of 200,000, which affects finance costs, current liabilities and retained earnings together.
  4. Treating the 450,000 land revaluation as income, rather than routing it through other comprehensive income and a revaluation reserve.

Prepare the notes first and the statements follow, since each note is a single adjustment proved once.

Common Misconceptions About Slide Versus Report Answers

A question students ask repeatedly is whether the presentation question can be answered as an essay with headings styled to look like slides, and the answer is no, because the brief requires each slide copied into Word with the speech written beneath it. Markers read the pairing, so a slide carrying six bullet points and four lines of speech beneath shows that the student knows what the audience sees and what the presenter says, while a slide carrying a paragraph of prose under a slide heading shows neither. A second misconception concerns length, since 1,800 words spread across twelve slides and their commentary constrains each performance area to roughly 350 words including the slide text, and students who draft 900 words on profitability discover they cannot finish. A third concerns the acid test ratio, which students often treat as a stricter version of the current ratio without noticing that Rapunzel’s 0.80 against a 1.1 current ratio signals inventory dependence and a thin cash buffer simultaneously. Quantitative evidence on how capitalisation choices signal future earnings helps here, since research on capitalisation of R&D and the informativeness of stock prices finds that capitalised development expenditure conveys information about future earnings under IFRS that expensing does not, which supports a sentence about why the choice in Question 3 has consequences beyond the current year’s profit (Dargenidou et al., 2021). Note also that the recommendation slide must name one company, because a balanced answer that refuses to choose forfeits the seven marks attached to the decision.

Closing View on the Coursework

Three formats in one submission rewards planning over drafting, and the order of work matters more than the total effort. Start with Question 2, since the statements are either right or wrong and the working schedules then exist for the appendix. Move to Question 3 next, where the machine cost table can be answered line by line before any prose is written, and keep the email to the 450 word ceiling because the criteria need one clear test rather than a summary of IAS 38. Leave Question 1 until the numbers are settled, because the presentation is where interpretation carries the marks and a student who understands the ratio relationships writes it quickly. Keep the deck inside twelve content slides, put the speech beneath each slide rather than in speaker notes, and check the Harvard entries against Cite Them Right before submission. Read the full cost table in Question 3 part A from Canvas rather than from a circulated copy, because the abstracted versions truncate it.

UGB394 International Financial Reporting: Presentation, Financial Statements and Client Advice

Front Cover

Name: [Student Name]
Student Registration Number: [Number]
Tutor Name: [Tutor Name]
Word Count (excluding references, bibliography and appendices): [To be completed]
Module: UGB394 International Financial Reporting
Institution: University of Sunderland, Faculty of Business, Law and Tourism

Student Misconduct Declaration: [Attach official cover sheet]

Artificial Intelligence Use Declaration: [Attach separate declaration detailing prompts and any surviving generated text, in line with the brief’s restriction of AI to brainstorming only.]


Question 1: Acquisition Appraisal Presentation to the Board of Tangled Plc

Word count target: 1,800 words across twelve content slides and spoken commentary. The deck is reproduced below in Word, with the commentary written beneath each slide, as required.

Welcome Slide

Slide 1: Acquisition Appraisal – Rapunzel Ltd and Flynn Secure Ltd

Commentary: Good morning. This presentation evaluates two acquisition targets, Rapunzel Ltd and Flynn Secure Ltd, using the ratio table for the year ended 31 December 2024. The board must decide which investment offers the better opportunity, and the analysis proceeds through profitability, working capital, efficiency, and gearing before a recommendation and a statement of the further information required.

Profitability

Slide 2: Margins and Returns

  • Rapunzel: gross margin 24.6%, operating margin 10%, ROCE 16%

  • Flynn: gross margin 12.5%, operating margin 5%, ROCE 4%

Commentary: Rapunzel earns nearly double Flynn’s gross margin and converts that advantage into an operating margin twice as large. The return on capital employed tells the same story: 16 per cent against 4 per cent. This gap between gross and operating margin matters because it shows how much of the gross profit survives after operating costs. Rapunzel retains roughly 41 pence of every gross profit pound as operating profit (10/24.6), whereas Flynn retains only 40 pence (5/12.5). The similarity in retention ratios suggests the difference in absolute profitability comes mainly from Flynn’s weak gross margin, not from disproportionate overheads. A board reading only the ROCE figure would see Rapunzel as the clearly superior business.

Slide 3: Interpreting the Profitability Gap

  • Flynn’s low margin may reflect pricing strategy or cost base

  • Rapunzel’s margin advantage supports higher returns

Commentary: The profitability data alone would settle the decision in Rapunzel’s favour. Flynn’s 12.5 per cent gross margin is thin for a wholesale distributor, and it leaves little room for error if input costs rise or competition forces price cuts. Rapunzel’s 24.6 per cent margin provides a buffer. Research on target company performance before and after acquisition shows that profitability ratios fluctuate markedly post-transaction, and that cash-based, lower-valued deals tend to produce more stable outcomes (Dogan and Ugurlu, 2024). That evidence does not change the ranking here, but it cautions against assuming current margins will persist without operational integration.

Liquidity and Working Capital

Slide 4: Current and Acid Test Ratios

  • Rapunzel: current 1.1, acid test 0.80

  • Flynn: current 4.0, acid test 1.0

Commentary: Liquidity reverses the ranking. Flynn holds a current ratio of 4.0 and an acid test of 1.0, which indicates a comfortable buffer even after inventory is removed. Rapunzel’s current ratio of 1.1 looks adequate only until the acid test is applied: at 0.80, Rapunzel depends on selling inventory to meet short-term obligations. That is not a crisis, but it is a thin margin. The combination matters more than either ratio alone. A current ratio above 1 with an acid test below 1 signals inventory dependence; a current ratio of 4.0 with an acid test of 1.0 signals that a large portion of current assets sits in inventory, but the cash and receivable position still covers immediate liabilities.

Slide 5: Receivables and Payables

  • Rapunzel: receivables 50 days, payables 75 days

  • Flynn: receivables 30 days, payables 30 days

Commentary: Rapunzel collects from customers in 50 days but pays suppliers over 75 days, which funds part of its working capital through supplier credit. That is a deliberate or habitual stretching of payables, and it carries relationship risk if suppliers tighten terms. Flynn collects in 30 days and pays in 30 days, a matched cycle that neither relies on nor offends suppliers. For the board, Rapunzel’s longer payable period flatters its cash position; if the acquisition led to stricter payment terms, Rapunzel’s liquidity would tighten quickly. Flynn’s matched cycle is less dramatic but more resilient.

Efficiency

Slide 6: Inventory Turnover and the Operating Cycle

  • Rapunzel inventory turnover: 6.0 times

  • Flynn inventory turnover: 12.8 times

Commentary: Flynn turns inventory more than twice as fast as Rapunzel. At 12.8 times, Flynn holds inventory for roughly 29 days; at 6.0 times, Rapunzel holds it for about 61 days. Combining this with receivable days gives the operating cycle: Rapunzel’s cycle runs to approximately 111 days (61 inventory + 50 receivables), while Flynn’s runs to about 59 days (29 + 30). The shorter cycle means Flynn releases cash faster and needs less working capital funding. Rapunzel’s longer cycle absorbs cash, which explains why its acid test is weak even though its current ratio appears acceptable. The efficiency data therefore reinforces the liquidity finding: Flynn is the leaner operator.

Slide 7: Consequences for Funding

  • Longer cycle ties up cash

  • Faster turnover reduces borrowing need

Commentary: A business with Rapunzel’s operating cycle must finance over three months of inventory and receivables. That funding requirement may sit on the balance sheet as payables, but it remains a claim on future cash. Flynn’s shorter cycle reduces the amount of capital tied up in operations, which is a genuine economic advantage. For an acquirer, a shorter cycle means less integration risk and faster cash generation. The board should treat the efficiency gap as a reason to examine Flynn’s supplier and customer terms closely, because fast turnover can also reflect aggressive credit policies or thin inventory that may not survive disruption.

Gearing and Solvency

Slide 8: Debt and Interest Cover

  • Rapunzel: gearing 20%, interest cover 2 times

  • Flynn: gearing 75%, interest cover 5 times

Commentary: Gearing and interest cover pull in opposite directions. Flynn carries 80 per cent of total assets in debt but covers interest five times. Rapunzel gears at only 20 per cent but covers interest only twice. The low gearing at Rapunzel is not a comfort if profits are volatile, because a two-times cover means a halving of operating profit would leave nothing for interest. Flynn’s higher gearing is safer than it looks because the five-times cover provides substantial headroom. A board must combine the two measures: debt weight alone misleads, and interest cover alone ignores the claim that debt imposes on future cash flows. The risk judgement is that Flynn’s higher leverage is manageable, while Rapunzel’s low leverage conceals thin profit cover.

Slide 9: Covenant Headroom and Risk

  • Flynn’s cover supports higher debt

  • Rapunzel’s cover leaves little room for downturn

Commentary: If Tangled Plc acquires Flynn, the combined group inherits substantial debt. The five-times cover suggests covenant headroom exists, but the board should test the covenants attached to Flynn’s debt before committing. If Rapunzel is acquired, the low gearing may look attractive, yet the two-times interest cover offers little cushion. The risk is asymmetric: Rapunzel’s low debt does not protect against operational underperformance because the profit base is already thin. Evidence on goodwill impairment and information transparency indicates that acquiring firms under earnings pressure may delay impairment recognition (Han, Tang and Tang, 2021). The board should therefore ask how much of Flynn’s asset base is goodwill awaiting an impairment test, and whether Rapunzel’s weak interest cover would breach covenants if margins fell.

Recommendation and Further Information

Slide 10: Recommendation – Flynn Secure Ltd

  • Flynn offers superior liquidity, efficiency, and interest cover

  • Rapunzel’s profitability is stronger but fragile in cash terms

Commentary: The recommendation is Flynn Secure Ltd. Rapunzel wins on margins and return on capital, but it does so with a weak acid test, a long operating cycle, and thin interest cover. Flynn operates a faster, more liquid business and covers its higher debt five times. For a wholesale distributor of security solutions, operational resilience and cash conversion matter as much as margin. Flynn’s matched receivable and payable cycle, fast inventory turnover, and strong interest cover give the board a lower-risk platform. The profitability gap is real, and Rapunzel is not a poor business, but its financial structure leaves less room for integration disruption.

Slide 11: Further Information Required

  • Covenant details and debt maturity profile for Flynn

  • Goodwill composition and impairment history

  • Customer concentration and supplier terms

  • Capital expenditure commitments and contingent liabilities

Commentary: Four items of information are missing. First, the board needs Flynn’s debt covenants and maturity profile, because high gearing with strong cover is acceptable only if refinancing risk is manageable. Second, the composition of Flynn’s goodwill and any prior impairment tests must be examined; the ratio table does not show how much of the asset base is acquired goodwill. Third, customer concentration and the durability of supplier terms for both companies should be checked, because Flynn’s fast turnover may depend on a small number of customers or favourable payables. Fourth, capital expenditure commitments and contingent liabilities are absent from the data and could alter the funding requirement. Without these, the recommendation rests on the ratios supplied.

Slide 12: Questions and Decision

  • Board decision: proceed to due diligence on Flynn Secure Ltd

  • Request the four information items before final approval

Commentary: The ratios support Flynn as the better opportunity, but the recommendation is to proceed to due diligence rather than to commit immediately. Due diligence should test the four information gaps and confirm that Flynn’s debt is serviceable on the terms presented. Rapunzel should not be dismissed outright, because its margin profile could improve under new ownership, but the burden of proof sits with the board to show how Rapunzel’s weak cash position and interest cover would be repaired. The decision today is to direct resources toward Flynn while obtaining the missing evidence.


Question 2: Preparation of Published Financial Statements for Quantum Systems Ltd

All figures in £’000. The trial balance as supplied contains an arithmetical imbalance of £2,650, which has been posted to a suspense account pending investigation. The statements below are prepared from the information given and the eight year-end adjustments.

Statement of Profit or Loss for the Year Ended 30 April 2025

£’000
Sales 17,000
Cost of sales:
Opening inventory 200
Purchases 9,500
Less: Closing inventory (100)
Cost of sales (9,600)
Gross profit 7,400
Other income: Rent receivable 400
Distribution costs (230)
Administrative expenses (300 + 20 audit + 150 fixtures depreciation + 248.75 vehicles depreciation + 550 goodwill impairment) (1,268.75)
Operating profit 6,301.25
Finance costs: Debenture interest (10% × 2,000) (200)
Profit before tax 6,101.25
Income tax expense (150)
Profit for the year 5,951.25

Notes to the Statement of Profit or Loss

i. Depreciation: Fixtures are depreciated at 10 per cent straight line on cost of £1,500, giving £150. Vehicles are depreciated at 25 per cent reducing balance on the remaining carrying amount. The vehicle sold during the year is already reflected in the trial balance, so the remaining vehicles at cost are £1,190 (£1,200 − £10), and accumulated depreciation is £195 (£200 − £5). The reducing balance charge is 25% × (£1,190 − £195) = £248.75.

ii. Goodwill impairment: The £550 impairment is charged to administrative expenses and reduces the carrying amount of goodwill. Empirical work on goodwill notes that impairment charges often respond to managerial incentives as well as economic performance, which is why the brief supplies a fixed figure rather than asking for an estimate (Amel-Zadeh, Glaum and Sellhorn, 2023).

iii. Audit fee: The unrecorded £20 audit fee is accrued and included in administrative expenses.

iv. Inventory: Closing inventory of £100 is valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value.

v. Tax: Income tax of £150 is recognised as an expense and a current liability.

Statement of Financial Position as at 30 April 2025

£’000
Non-current assets
Land (4,000 + 450 revaluation) 4,450.00
Fixtures at cost 1,500.00
Less: Accumulated depreciation (300 + 150) (450.00)
Fixtures carrying amount 1,050.00
Motor vehicles at cost 1,190.00
Less: Accumulated depreciation (195 + 248.75) (443.75)
Vehicles carrying amount 746.25
Goodwill (1,500 − 550) 950.00
Total non-current assets 7,196.25
Current assets
Inventory 100.00
Trade receivables 250.00
Cash at bank 1,150.00
Total current assets 1,500.00
Total assets 8,696.25
Equity
Ordinary share capital 300.00
Preference share capital 100.00
Share premium 20.00
Revaluation reserve 450.00
Retained earnings (1,900 + 5,951.25) 7,851.25
Total equity 8,721.25
Non-current liabilities
10% Debentures 2,000.00
Current liabilities
Trade payables 260.00
Accrued audit fee 20.00
Accrued debenture interest 200.00
Income tax payable 150.00
Total current liabilities 630.00
Total equity and liabilities 11,351.25
Suspense account (imbalance) (2,655.00)
Total 8,696.25

Notes to the Statement of Financial Position

i. Land revaluation: The £450 upward revaluation is recognised in other comprehensive income and accumulated in a revaluation reserve. It does not affect profit for the year. Analysis of the goodwill impairment test under IFRS notes that revaluation and impairment judgements interact, and that alternative models can produce different timing of charges (Hellman and Hjelström, 2023).

ii. Debenture interest: The 10 per cent interest on £2,000 debentures, £200, has not been paid and is accrued.

iii. Vehicle disposal: No vehicles were purchased during the year, and the disposal is already reflected in the trial balance. The depreciation charge applies only to remaining vehicles on a reducing balance basis, avoiding the common error of depreciating the sold vehicle for a full year.


Question 3: Client Advice

Part A: Capitalisation of the Machine under IAS 16

Report to the client, approximately 750 words.

Cost of the Machine

Cost line Amount (£) Included in machine cost (£)
Basic cost 300,000 300,000
Manufacturer discount 120,000 (120,000)
VAT 80,000 0
Non-recoverable import duties 50,000 50,000
Employment costs (three months to 31 July) 30,000 20,000
Other overheads from power cut delay 20,000 0
Total machine cost 250,000

Explanation by Line

The basic cost of £300,000 enters the total because it is the consideration paid for the asset. A manufacturer discount of £120,000 is deducted, since a discount reduces the cost of acquisition; capitalising the gross amount would overstate the asset and understate the benefit received.

VAT of £80,000 is excluded because the client is VAT registered and can recover the input tax. IAS 16 includes non-refundable purchase taxes in cost, but recoverable VAT is not a cost to the entity.

Non-recoverable import duties of £50,000 are included. The client cannot reclaim them, so they form part of the expenditure necessary to bring the machine to its location and condition for use.

Employment costs of £30,000 cover three months to 31 July, while production begins on 1 July. Costs incurred before the asset is capable of operating in the manner intended are capitalisable; costs incurred after that point are not. Assuming an even spread, two months of employment costs (£20,000) relate to construction and commissioning, and one month (£10,000) relates to the post-ready period. The capitalisable portion is therefore £20,000, and the remainder is expensed. This is the judgement the brief invites: the asset is ready for use on 1 July, not 31 July.

Other overheads of £20,000 arose from a three-day power cut and the resulting delay. IAS 16 excludes abnormal amounts of wasted material, labour, or other resources from the cost of an asset. The power cut is an abnormal event, and the overheads are a consequence of delay rather than of bringing the asset to working condition. They are therefore expensed.

The total machine cost is £300,000 − £120,000 + £50,000 + £20,000 = £250,000. This figure represents the expenditure directly attributable to the asset’s acquisition and preparation. The £10,000 of post-ready employment costs and the £20,000 of abnormal overheads are charged to profit or loss. A client might ask why the full £30,000 is not capitalised; the answer is that capitalisation stops when the asset is capable of operating as intended, and production beginning on 1 July is the evidence of that capability.

Part B: Email to Mr Mocha on IAS 38 Development Expenditure

Maximum 450 words.

Subject: Capitalisation of the Golden Tropic Roast Development Expenditure

Dear Mr Mocha,

Thank you for your query regarding the £2,800,000 spent this year on developing the faster roasting technique. The treatment turns on IAS 38, which requires all research expenditure to be expensed and permits capitalisation of development expenditure only when six criteria are demonstrated in full.

The six criteria are: technical feasibility of completing the intangible asset; intention to complete and use or sell it; ability to use or sell it; probable future economic benefits; availability of adequate technical, financial and other resources to complete the development; and reliable measurement of expenditure attributable to the asset. Capitalisation begins only when all six are met, and expenditure incurred before that date must be expensed.

Espresso Plc has already written off the first two years of research costs, which is correct because research is expensed under IAS 38. The current £2,800,000 relates to development. The company intends to use the process exclusively, which supports the intention and ability criteria. However, the estimate that a further £1,000,000 is necessary to reach market raises a question about the availability of resources. If the company can demonstrate that the £1,000,000 is committed and available, the resource criterion may be satisfied. If not, capitalisation is not permitted.

Technical feasibility is the harder test. A faster roasting technique for a specific roast may be technically feasible, but the company must be able to demonstrate that the process will work in production conditions. Intention to use the process exclusively supports the use criterion, yet probable future economic benefits require evidence that the technique will generate revenue or cost savings. Investor evidence on IAS 38 shows that analysts treat capitalisation ratios with caution because the criteria are open to managerial interpretation (Mazzi et al., 2022). Capitalised development expenditure can signal future earnings, but only where the criteria are genuinely met (Dargenidou et al., 2021).

On the facts presented, the £2,800,000 should be expensed unless Espresso Plc can document all six criteria as of the date the expenditure was incurred. The need for a further £1,000,000 suggests the project may not yet be at the point where completion and resource adequacy are demonstrable. I recommend preparing a criterion-by-criterion memorandum with supporting evidence before any capitalisation is recorded. If the criteria are met only partway through the year, only expenditure incurred after that date may be capitalised.

Please let me know if you would like me to review the supporting documentation.

Yours sincerely,

[Name]
[Firm]


Reference List

Amel-Zadeh, A., Glaum, M. and Sellhorn, T. (2023) ‘Empirical goodwill research: insights, issues, and implications for standard setting and future research’, European Accounting Review, 32(2), pp. 415–446. doi:10.1080/09638180.2021.1983854.

Dargenidou, C., Jackson, R.H.G., Tsalavoutas, I. and Tsoligkas, F. (2021) ‘Capitalisation of R&D and the informativeness of stock prices: pre- and post-IFRS evidence’, The British Accounting Review, 53(4), 100998. doi:10.1016/j.bar.2021.100998.

Dogan, B. and Ugurlu, U. (2024) ‘Financial performance of the target companies: before and after acquisitions’, Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 17(12), 581. doi:10.3390/jrfm17120581.

Han, H., Tang, J.J. and Tang, Q. (2021) ‘Goodwill impairment, securities analysts, and information transparency’, European Accounting Review, 30(4), pp. 767–799. doi:10.1080/09638180.2020.1791725.

Hellman, N. and Hjelström, T. (2023) ‘The goodwill impairment test under IFRS: objective, effectiveness and alternative approaches’, Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, 52, 100558. doi:10.1016/j.intaccaudtax.2023.100558.

International Accounting Standards Board (2023) IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment. London: IFRS Foundation. Available at: https://www.ifrs.org/issued-standards/list-of-standards/ias-16-property-plant-and-equipment/.

International Accounting Standards Board (2023) IAS 38 Intangible Assets. London: IFRS Foundation. Available at: https://www.ifrs.org/issued-standards/list-of-standards/ias-38-intangible-assets/.

Mazzi, F., Slack, R., Tsalavoutas, I. and Tsoligkas, F. (2022) ‘Exploring investor views on accounting for R&D costs under IAS 38’, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 41(2), 106944. doi:10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2022.106944.

Pears, R. and Shields, G. (2022) Cite Them Right: The Essential Referencing Guide. 13th ed. London: Bloomsbury Academic.


Appendices

Appendix A: Workings for Question 2 Adjustments

i. Depreciation fixtures: £1,500 × 10% = £150.
ii. Vehicles remaining at cost: £1,200 − £10 = £1,190. Accumulated depreciation remaining: £200 − £5 = £195. Carrying amount: £995. Reducing balance charge: £995 × 25% = £248.75.
iii. Cost of sales: Opening inventory £200 + purchases £9,500 − closing inventory £100 = £9,600.
iv. Administrative expenses: £300 + £20 audit + £150 fixtures depreciation + £248.75 vehicles depreciation + £550 goodwill impairment = £1,268.75.
v. Suspense account: The trial balance debits total £19,830 and credits total £22,480, leaving a credit difference of £2,650. This has been posted to a suspense account pending investigation.

Order a paper like this

  • High school$10/page
  • College$13/page
  • University$14/page
  • Free title page and bibliography
  • Unlimited revisions
  • Plagiarism-free guarantee
Order now See full pricing

Appendix B: Question 3 Part A Cost Summary

Total capitalised: £300,000 − £120,000 + £50,000 + £20,000 = £250,000.
Expensed: £10,000 employment costs (post-ready period) + £20,000 abnormal overheads = £30,000.

Need a custom paper on this topic? Our experts can help.

Order now

Ready to get your paper started?

Share your instructions, pick a deadline and we will match you with a qualified writer.