Lowest price from $10 per page Start saving now →
NHS FPX Assessment

Conscientious Objection and Patient Access to Abortion Care

NHS-FPX4000: Developing a Health Care Perspective
Assessment 3: Applying Ethical Principles
Capella University | 3–5 pages | APA 7th edition | Scoring Guide


Context

This assessment sits inside the Capella University NHS-FPX4000 course for the Fall 2026 semester. Students in the School of Nursing and Health Sciences complete a 3–5 page paper that applies a three-component ethical decision-making model to a case study from the Assessment 03 Supplement. The paper carries the weight of the course competency on ethical principles and professional codes. The task rewards a specific sequence: summarise the facts, identify the ethical problem, analyse the factors that produced it, and propose a defensible solution. A paper that recounts the case and appends a generic opinion will miss the scoring guide criteria. The page limit is tight enough that every paragraph must do analytical work.


Task Description

Select one case study from the Assessment 03 Supplement. Develop a solution to the ethical dilemma the case presents by applying ethical principles and a recognised decision-making model. Structure the paper in four connected moves. First, summarise the facts and identify the stakeholders. Second, name the ethical problem and explain why it constitutes a dilemma rather than a simple disagreement. Third, apply the three components of the Capella Ethical Decision-Making Model (moral awareness, moral judgment, and ethical behaviour) to analyse the factors that contributed to the problem. Fourth, propose a solution that a reasonable health care professional could defend, and connect that solution to the ANA Code of Ethics and at least one peer-reviewed journal article. Do not write a case summary with a recommendation tacked on the end. Build the recommendation from the analysis.


Requirements

  1. Use APA 7th edition for title page, in-text citations, and references.

  2. Write 3–5 typed, double-spaced pages, excluding the title page and reference page.

  3. Summarise the selected case study and identify the ethical problem in the first section.

  4. Apply the three components of the ethical decision-making model to the factors that contributed to the problem.

  5. Cite at least one current peer-reviewed journal article from the Capella library, published within the last 3–5 years, and apply its principles to the analysis.

  6. Reference the ANA Code of Ethics and connect specific provisions to the proposed solution.

  7. Propose a solution that addresses the ethical problem and explains how the solution respects the relevant principles.

  8. Submit the paper through the course room by the posted deadline.


Scoring Guide

Criterion Weight Distinguished (90–100%) Proficient (70–89%) Basic (0–69%)
Summarise the facts and use the decision-making model 25% Summarises the case with precision, names all relevant stakeholders, and applies all three model components to the factors that produced the dilemma. Summarises the case and applies the model, but one component is thin or the stakeholder analysis is incomplete. Summary is vague or missing. Model is named but not applied.
Analyse the ethical problem and contributing factors 25% Names the ethical problem clearly, distinguishes it from a clinical or legal problem, and explains how the contributing factors interacted. Names the problem but the analysis of contributing factors is partial or descriptive. Problem is misidentified or described only in general terms. No factor analysis.
Apply peer-reviewed evidence and the ANA Code 20% Integrates at least one peer-reviewed article with specific application, not just a citation. Connects named ANA provisions to the analysis. Cites a peer-reviewed article and the ANA Code but the application is broad or disconnected from the case. Missing peer-reviewed source or fails to connect the ANA Code to the case.
Propose a defensible solution 20% Solution follows from the analysis, addresses the stakeholders, and explains which ethical principles it honours and which it may trade off. Solution is plausible but not fully grounded in the preceding analysis. Solution is generic, unsupported, or disconnected from the ethical problem.
Academic and APA standards 10% APA 7th edition is correct. Writing is clear and concise. Meets page length. Minor APA errors. Writing is understandable but contains mechanical issues. Page length is close to the limit. Major APA errors. Writing impedes comprehension. Falls outside the page limit.

Sample Answer

The case study involving a patient who refuses a recommended blood transfusion after a motor vehicle accident presents a dilemma that sits at the intersection of autonomy and beneficence. The patient is competent, has been informed that refusal will likely result in death, and maintains the refusal. The emergency department nurse faces a conflict between respecting the patient’s autonomous decision and the professional obligation to preserve life. Applying the moral awareness component of the decision-making model requires recognising that this is not a question of whether the patient understands the consequences. The patient does understand. The dilemma arises because two legitimate ethical commitments point in opposite directions. Moral judgment then requires the nurse to weigh those commitments against the professional code and the clinical context. The ANA Code of Ethics Provision 1 states that the nurse practices with compassion and respect for the inherent dignity, worth, and unique attributes of every person (American Nurses Association, 2015). That provision does not resolve the dilemma by itself. It frames the terms of the resolution.

A structured ethical reflection model helps the nurse move from recognition to action without abandoning either principle. Paulsen et al. (2023) describe a dialogue-based approach in which the clinician works through the moral dilemma by naming the conflicting values, identifying the parties affected, and testing possible responses against the professional code (Can a structured model of ethical reflection be used to teach ethics to nursing students?, https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.1373). The nurse in this case would document the refusal, confirm capacity through a second clinical assessment, and initiate an ethics consultation rather than treating the refusal as a problem to be overridden. The ethical behaviour component of the model then becomes concrete: the nurse advocates for the patient’s stated wishes while ensuring that the care team has exhausted every opportunity to inform and support the decision. That is not a compromise between autonomy and beneficence. It is a sequenced response that honours both.


Deepening the Ethical Analysis

The sample above treats moral awareness as more than a preliminary step. That distinction matters because the scoring guide penalises papers that name the model and then write a case summary. Moral awareness requires the nurse to recognise that a dilemma exists before any decision about action. Rushton et al. (2024) argue that ethical decision-making frameworks in nursing fail most often at the recognition stage, when clinicians mistake a difficult conversation for a resolved dilemma and move directly to a solution (An ethical framework for human resource allocation in nursing, https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NUMA.0001006081.16046.9f). A paper that skips recognition and jumps to a recommendation will satisfy the surface requirement and miss the analytical weight of the criterion.

What the Scoring Guide Actually Rewards

Students often assume the solution section carries the most points and spend disproportionate time there. The scoring guide weights the analysis of contributing factors and the application of the model equally with the solution. A weak analysis cannot be rescued by a strong recommendation. The most common error involves conflating an ethical dilemma with a clinical disagreement. A family that wants a different treatment plan is not automatically presenting an ethical dilemma. The dilemma arises when two or more ethical principles collide and no option satisfies all of them. A second error involves citing the peer-reviewed article without applying it. The rubric requires the article’s principles to do analytical work in the paper, not to sit in a parenthetical citation. A third error involves the ANA Code. Referencing the Code in general terms does not meet the criterion. The paper should name a specific provision and show how it bears on the case.

  • Moral awareness is a recognition task, not a definition to be quoted.

  • The ANA provision should appear in the analysis of the solution, not only in the introduction.

  • The peer-reviewed article should supply a concept or finding that the paper could not make as well without it.


Conclusion

The NHS-FPX4000 Assessment 3 rewards a paper that moves in a straight line from facts to problem to analysis to solution. The scoring guide is not complicated. It asks for all three components of the model, a named ethical problem, a peer-reviewed source that does real work, and a solution that respects the ANA Code. A paper that summarises the case and recommends “patient-centred care” without tracing how the recommendation follows from the analysis will lose points in every criterion. The page limit is an advantage if the writer uses it to develop one argument rather than to survey several. A strong submission reads like a nurse thinking through a hard situation in real time, with the model as a structure rather than a decoration.


References

American Nurses Association. (2015). Code of ethics for nurses with interpretive statements. https://www.nursingworld.org/practice-policy/nursing-excellence/ethics/code-of-ethics-for-nurses/

Capella University. (2024). Ethical decision-making model [Interactive media]. Courseroom.

Paulsen, J. E., Næss, T., & Gundersen, D. (2023). Can a structured model of ethical reflection be used to teach ethics to nursing students? An approach to teaching nursing students a tool for systematic ethical reflection. Nursing Open, 10(2), 721–729. https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.1373

Rushton, C. H., Raso, R., McCausland, M., Gosselin, T., Joseph, M. L., & Grant, M. (2024). An ethical framework for human resource allocation in nursing. Nursing Management, 55(3), 8–16. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NUMA.0001006081.16046.9f

Conscientious Objection and Professional Responsibility in Nursing

Nurse Amelia Brooks faces an ethical dilemma because her religious objection to abortion conflicts with Sophie Turner’s right to receive timely, nondiscriminatory reproductive care. The central ethical problem is not whether Amelia may hold personal beliefs; she may. The problem arises because a refusal to participate, if poorly managed, could delay or deny care to a patient who has already made a lawful and autonomous decision. A defensible resolution requires Amelia to disclose her objection promptly, request reassignment without abandoning Sophie, and ensure that the patient receives uninterrupted care from a willing, qualified clinician.

Case Summary and Stakeholders

Amelia Brooks is an experienced nurse at Riverside Medical Center. Dr. Rebecca Martin, the lead obstetrician, asks Amelia to assist with an elective abortion for Sophie Turner, a 24-year-old graduate student. Amelia’s religious upbringing has shaped a strong personal opposition to abortion. She believes that assisting with the procedure would violate her conscience and moral convictions.

At the same time, Amelia recognizes that Sophie has a right to make decisions about her own body and reproductive health. Amelia also understands that professional nursing requires care that is respectful, competent, and free from discrimination. The case therefore places two serious moral claims in tension: Amelia’s claim to moral integrity and Sophie’s claim to autonomous, timely health care.

Several stakeholders carry interests in the outcome. Sophie has the most direct interest because the procedure affects her body, health, safety, reproductive autonomy, and access to care. Dr. Martin carries responsibility for coordinating safe obstetric care and ensuring that the procedure proceeds without unnecessary delay. Amelia has an interest in preserving her conscience and professional integrity. Riverside Medical Center has an institutional duty to maintain safe staffing, clear conscience policies, and equitable patient access. Other patients and staff members also have a stake because a poorly handled objection can disrupt care delivery and weaken trust in the organization.

The Ethical Problem

The ethical problem is a conflict between conscientious objection and professional responsibility. Amelia’s objection is sincere, but Sophie’s request for abortion care is also ethically legitimate. Autonomy supports Sophie’s authority to decide what happens to her body. Beneficence requires the care team to act in ways that promote Sophie’s well-being. Nonmaleficence requires the team to prevent avoidable physical, emotional, and procedural harm.

A simple disagreement would exist if Amelia and Dr. Martin merely preferred different approaches to care. The situation becomes a dilemma because no available response satisfies every moral obligation completely. If Amelia participates, she may experience a serious violation of conscience. If she refuses without arranging alternative coverage, Sophie may experience delay, stigma, reduced access, or harm. The dilemma therefore concerns how Amelia can honour her conscience while ensuring that her refusal does not become a barrier to Sophie’s care.

The problem is ethical rather than merely clinical or legal. Clinically, the team must determine whether the procedure can be performed safely and whether appropriate staff are available. Legally, institutional policy and applicable law may govern refusal and accommodation. Ethically, however, the deeper question concerns the fair distribution of burdens: Sophie should not bear the cost of Amelia’s conscience, while Amelia should not be forced to abandon her moral integrity without a reasonable alternative.

Moral Awareness

Moral awareness requires Amelia to recognize that the situation contains competing moral claims before she decides how to respond. She must see that her discomfort is not simply a workplace inconvenience or a preference about the assigned task. Her objection concerns a deeply held belief about the moral status of abortion and her own participation in the procedure.

At the same time, moral awareness requires Amelia to recognize Sophie’s vulnerability. Sophie has made a decision about her own body, and she depends on the health care team to provide care without judgment, delay, or coercion. Grace et al. (2024) argue that conscientious objection in nursing must be evaluated through professional responsibility, because a nurse’s refusal can create real harms for patients when alternative care is not promptly arranged. Awareness therefore includes recognizing both claims: Amelia’s integrity matters, but Sophie’s access to care also carries moral weight.

Contributing factors deepen the conflict. Amelia’s religious upbringing has shaped a firm moral conviction, which gives her objection sincerity and seriousness. Institutional pressure may also contribute if the hospital expects nurses to accept assignments without a clear process for conscience-based refusals. Dr. Martin’s request creates an immediate operational demand, while Sophie’s need for timely care limits the time available for reflection. These factors interact: a sincere belief becomes an ethical problem when it meets a patient’s immediate need for care and an institution that has not clearly planned for such conflicts.

Moral Judgment

Moral judgment requires Amelia to weigh the competing obligations and determine the response that best protects both moral integrity and patient welfare. She should not treat her objection as absolute permission to obstruct care. Conversely, the hospital should not treat professional duty as permission to disregard a nurse’s sincere moral convictions. A defensible judgment lies between those extremes.

Grace et al. (2024) provide a useful standard: conscientious objection may be ethically tolerable when it does not create undue harm to the patient and when the clinician’s moral integrity is genuinely threatened. Their framework emphasizes that objection cannot be arbitrary, discriminatory, or based on convenience. Amelia’s objection appears sincere and religiously grounded, so it deserves respectful consideration. However, its ethical acceptability depends on whether Sophie can receive timely care from another qualified provider.

Amelia should therefore judge that she may request exemption from direct participation, provided she does so immediately and supports continuity of care. She should notify Dr. Martin and the appropriate supervisor before the procedure, rather than refusing at the bedside or after preparations have begun. She should also document the objection professionally, avoid discussing her religious beliefs with Sophie, and participate in any non-direct aspects of care that do not violate her conscience. This approach protects Sophie’s autonomy while respecting Amelia’s moral limits.

Ethical Behaviour

Ethical behaviour turns judgment into action. Amelia’s first responsibility is prompt disclosure. She should inform Dr. Martin and her nurse manager as soon as the assignment is known, allowing the institution to identify another nurse without compromising Sophie’s schedule or safety. Grace et al. (2024) note that conscience-based refusals should be made known in advance, in time for alternative arrangements to be made.

Amelia should then support a handoff that preserves Sophie’s dignity. She should not pressure Sophie to change her decision, question her motives, or make the patient feel responsible for Amelia’s beliefs. She should provide only necessary, neutral information and transfer care respectfully to a colleague who can assist. If no alternative nurse is immediately available, Amelia should escalate the concern to leadership rather than abandon the patient or allow the procedure to proceed without appropriate support.

The institution also bears ethical responsibility. Riverside Medical Center should maintain a written conscience policy that requires early notification, identifies backup staffing, protects patients from delay, and prevents discrimination. The American Nurses Association states that nurses should not be forced to violate their conscience, but that policies must ensure that conscientious objection does not prevent safe, equitable patient care (American Nurses Association, 2021). Ethical behaviour therefore involves both individual action and institutional planning.

Defensible Resolution

The most defensible resolution is a structured accommodation process that protects Sophie’s access to care while respecting Amelia’s conscience. Amelia should immediately notify Dr. Martin and her supervisor of her objection, request reassignment from direct participation, and assist with a respectful transfer of care. The nurse manager should confirm that a qualified colleague is available before the procedure begins. If staffing is insufficient, leadership should activate an on-call nurse, redistribute nonessential duties, or delay the procedure only when medically appropriate and only until alternative coverage is secured.

This resolution honours autonomy because Sophie retains control over her reproductive decision and receives care without coercion. It supports beneficence and nonmaleficence because it prevents avoidable delay, emotional harm, and disruption of safe care. It also respects Amelia’s moral integrity because it allows her to withdraw from direct participation without abandoning professional responsibility. The approach acknowledges a trade-off: Amelia may experience disappointment or professional inconvenience, while the institution carries the administrative burden of arranging coverage. Those burdens are more defensible than placing the burden of delayed care on Sophie.

The ANA Code of Ethics supports this resolution. Provision 1 requires nurses to practice with compassion and respect for every person’s inherent dignity and worth (American Nurses Association, 2025). Provision 3 requires nurses to establish trusting relationships and advocate for patients’ rights, health, and safety (American Nurses Association, 2025). Amelia honours these provisions by treating Sophie respectfully, protecting her access to care, and ensuring that her objection does not become a barrier to treatment. The Code also recognizes that conscience matters, but it frames conscience within a professional duty to ensure that patients are not harmed or abandoned.

Conclusion

Amelia Brooks can honour both her conscience and her professional obligations through early disclosure, respectful reassignment, and active support for continuity of care. The ethical dilemma arises because Amelia’s sincere religious conviction conflicts with Sophie’s right to timely, nondiscriminatory abortion care. Moral awareness identifies the competing claims; moral judgment determines that objection is acceptable only when patient access remains protected; ethical behaviour requires prompt notification, professional handoff, and institutional backup staffing. A resolution grounded in the ANA Code of Ethics and the framework advanced by Grace et al. (2024) prevents Amelia’s personal beliefs from becoming an obstacle to Sophie’s autonomous decision. The strongest ethical response does not force either person to abandon a core commitment; it arranges care so that both conscience and patient welfare receive meaningful protection.

References

American Nurses Association. (2021). Nurses’ professional responsibility to promote ethical practice environments. https://www.nursingworld.org/globalassets/practiceandpolicy/nursing-excellence/ana-position-statements/nursing-practice/nurses-professional-responsibility-to-promote-ethical-practice-environments-2021-final.pdf

American Nurses Association. (2025). Code of ethics for nurses. https://codeofethics.ana.org/home

Order a paper like this

  • High school$10/page
  • College$13/page
  • University$14/page
  • Free title page and bibliography
  • Unlimited revisions
  • Plagiarism-free guarantee
Order now See full pricing

Capella University. (2024). Ethical decision-making model [Interactive media]. Capella Courseroom.

Grace, P. J., Peter, E., Lachman, V. D., Johnson, N. L., Kenny, D. J., & Wocial, L. D. (2024). Professional responsibility, nurses, and conscientious objection: A framework for ethical evaluation. Nursing Ethics, 31(2–3), 243–255. https://doi.org/10.1177/09697330231180749

Need a custom paper on this topic? Our experts can help.

Order now

Ready to get your paper started?

Share your instructions, pick a deadline and we will match you with a qualified writer.