SNHU ENG 123: English Composition II
Summative Assessment: Persuasive Essay (Argumentative Research Essay)
Fall 2026 | 5–7 pages | MLA or APA | 200 points
Context
This summative assessment closes the persuasion sequence in Southern New Hampshire University’s ENG 123 for the Fall 2026 semester. Students submit a 5–7 page persuasive essay that argues a debatable position on an issue tied to their degree field or intended career. The essay carries 200 points and replaces a final examination. The rubric weights the thesis, the use of evidence, and the refutation of an opposing viewpoint. A paper that summarises both sides without taking a position will miss the weight-bearing criteria. The page limit sits between the shorter writing plan and the final reflection, which means every body paragraph must advance the argument rather than survey the topic.
Task Description
Select a debatable issue related to your major, your intended career field, or a professional problem you expect to encounter. Take a clear position. Build an argument supported by credible research, and address at least one significant opposing viewpoint. Write a 5–7 page essay in MLA or APA format. The introduction must present the issue, state the thesis, and preview the argument’s structure. Body paragraphs must combine a focused claim, sourced evidence, and analysis that connects the evidence to the thesis. One paragraph must summarise the strongest opposing view and refute it with evidence rather than assertion. The conclusion must restate the thesis in light of the evidence, summarise the argument’s main moves, and draw a conclusion that matters to the audience. Do not write a report that lists arguments on both sides. Write an argument that takes a side and defends it.
Requirements
- Use MLA 9th edition or APA 7th edition consistently. Do not mix styles.
- Write 5–7 pages of body text, double-spaced, 12-point Times New Roman, with one-inch margins. The Works Cited or References page does not count toward the page limit.
- Include a thesis that states a debatable position, not a statement of fact or a question.
- Integrate evidence from at least five credible sources. At least three must be peer-reviewed journal articles, government reports, or authoritative professional publications.
- Address and refute one significant opposing viewpoint. Summarise the opposing view fairly before rebutting it.
- Include a Works Cited or References page formatted in the chosen style.
- Submit the essay as a Microsoft Word document through Brightspace by the posted deadline. Late submissions receive a 10 percent deduction per day.
Rubric
| Criterion | Weight | Exemplary (90–100%) | Proficient (70–89%) | Needs Improvement (0–69%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction and Thesis | 20% | Introduces the issue with sufficient context, states a precise and debatable thesis, and previews the argument’s structure. The thesis commits to a position a reasonable person could contest. | Introduces the issue and states a thesis, but the thesis is broad or the preview is missing. The position is clear but underdeveloped. | Introduction lacks context or the thesis is a statement of fact, a question, or a summary of both sides. No preview of the argument. |
| Evidence and Analysis | 30% | Each body paragraph makes a focused claim, integrates credible evidence, and explains how the evidence supports the thesis. Sources are quoted or paraphrased accurately and cited correctly. | Body paragraphs contain claims and evidence, but the analysis is thin in one or two paragraphs. Some evidence is dropped in without explanation. | Body paragraphs summarise sources without connecting them to the thesis. Evidence is insufficient, irrelevant, or misread. |
| Counterargument and Refutation | 20% | Summarises the strongest opposing view fairly and refutes it with specific evidence and reasoning. The refutation strengthens the essay’s own position rather than changing the subject. | Addresses an opposing view, but the summary is partial or the refutation relies on assertion rather than evidence. | Omits the opposing view, misrepresents it, or refutes it with a straw man. |
| Conclusion | 15% | Restates the thesis in light of the evidence, summarises the argument’s main moves without repetition, and draws a conclusion that matters to the audience. | Restates the thesis and summarises the argument, but the conclusion is predictable or does not return to the audience’s stake in the issue. | Conclusion repeats the introduction, introduces a new argument, or ends without connecting the evidence to a larger point. |
| Academic Standards | 15% | MLA or APA formatting is correct throughout. Writing is clear, concise, and free of grammatical errors. Meets the page limit and the source minimum. | Minor formatting errors. Writing is understandable but contains some mechanical issues. Meets the page limit with little margin. | Major formatting errors. Writing impedes comprehension. Falls short of the page limit or the source minimum. |
Sample Answer: Thesis and Counterargument Paragraph
State legislatures should require all public four-year universities to accept transfer credits from regionally accredited community colleges when the student earned a grade of C or higher in a course that matches a lower-division requirement. The argument rests on three claims: transfer students who lose credits take longer to graduate, the loss falls hardest on low-income students, and the state has a financial interest in shortening time to degree. Each claim requires evidence, not assertion. A thesis that says “transfer credit policies are complicated” states a fact. A thesis that says “states should mandate transfer credit acceptance” takes a side. The difference matters because the rubric rewards a position a reasonable person could contest. A body paragraph that summarises the complexity of articulation agreements without arguing for a solution will meet the minimum and miss the thesis criterion.
The strongest objection to a state mandate is that it would force universities to accept courses that do not meet their academic standards, diluting the value of the degree. That objection deserves a fair hearing before it is rebutted. Al Bulushi (2022) examined how students use sources in counterargument writing and found that many cite background or confirmatory sources rather than engaging with opposing evidence (Al Bulushi, 2022, source choice and use in counterargument writing). The same pattern appears in student essays that dismiss transfer mandates without examining the actual articulation data. A stronger rebuttal would acknowledge that some courses may not transfer, then show that statewide articulation agreements in states like Florida and Texas already use faculty review panels to protect standards while increasing credit acceptance. The counterargument paragraph should not pretend the objection is foolish. It should show why the objection does not outweigh the costs of the status quo.
Refutation Beyond Assertion
The sample above treats refutation as an evidence problem, not a rhetorical flourish. Students often write “critics say X, but they are wrong” and count that as a counterargument. That move fails the rubric because it asserts rather than demonstrates. A stronger refutation summarises the opposing view in terms its proponents would recognise, then supplies specific evidence that limits the objection’s scope. The most common error involves choosing an opposing view that no serious person holds. A straw man is easier to refute and earns fewer points. The rubric asks for a significant opposing viewpoint, which means the strongest version of the objection, not the weakest. A student who writes about transfer credit mandates should engage with the academic standards objection, not with a fringe claim that universities oppose transfer students out of snobbery. Refutation is a test of the essay’s own evidence, not a performance of confidence.
Evidence Quality Over Source Count
The rubric requires five credible sources, but the number matters less than how the sources function in the argument. A paper that cites five sources in the introduction and never returns to them will meet the minimum and miss the evidence criterion. Each body paragraph should integrate at least one source that supplies a specific finding, statistic, or documented case. General references to “research shows” without a citation do not count as evidence. Government reports and peer-reviewed studies carry more weight than opinion pieces, though an authoritative policy analysis can serve as a source if the writer explains why it is credible. The student who uses a single well-chosen source to support a specific claim will outperform the student who lists five sources that no paragraph actually needs.
Audience and Tone Calibration
The essay’s audience is not the instructor alone. The rubric does not state an external audience, yet the strongest essays write for readers who disagree or who have not considered the issue. That choice affects word choice, evidence selection, and the counterargument’s tone. A paper written for a hostile reader will summarise the opposing view with more care and will avoid sarcasm. A paper written only for a grader will assert positions without earning them. The conclusion should return to the audience’s stake in the issue: why does this argument matter to someone who is not already convinced? The shift from “here is my opinion” to “here is why this matters to you” separates a passing essay from a strong one.
Conclusion
The ENG 123 persuasive essay rewards a writer who takes a position and defends it with evidence. The rubric is not a checklist of features to include; it is a test of whether the essay’s parts work together. A thesis that commits to a contestable claim, body paragraphs that analyse rather than summarise, a counterargument that engages the strongest objection, and a conclusion that returns to the audience’s stake in the issue will clear the weight-bearing criteria. The page limit gives enough room to develop an argument and not enough room to pad it. A paper that answers the question of why the reader should care will do more than a paper that answers the question of what the sources say.
References
Al Bulushi, Z. (2022). Source choice and use in counterargument writing. TESOL Journal, 33(2), e646. https://doi.org/10.1002/tesj.646
Aull, L., & Ross, V. (2020). From cow paths to conversation: Rethinking the argumentative essay. Pedagogy, 20(1), 21–34. https://doi.org/10.1215/15314200-7878975
Casado-Ledesma, L., Cuevas, I., Van den Bergh, H., & Mateos, M. (2021). Teaching argumentative synthesis writing through deliberative dialogues: Instructional practices in secondary education. Instructional Science, 49(4), 487–516. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11251-021-09548-3
McCarthy, P. M., Kaddoura, N. W., Ahmed, K., Buck, R. H., Thomas, A. M., Al-harthy, A., & Duran, N. D. (2021). Metadiscourse and counterargument integration in student argumentative papers. English Language Teaching, 14(6), 96–113. https://doi.org/10.5539/elt.v14n6p96
States Should Require Public Universities to Accept Community College Transfer Credits
Community college remains a common route to a bachelor’s degree, particularly for students who need lower tuition, flexible schedules, or a local starting point. Yet many students who succeed in transferring discover that credits they earned do not count toward their intended degree. State legislatures should require public four-year universities to accept transfer credits from regionally accredited community colleges when a student earned at least a C in a course that matches a lower-division requirement. A statewide mandate would reduce credit loss, limit the extra time and money students spend repeating courses, and protect low-income students from policies that quietly make a bachelor’s degree harder to finish. The argument rests on three claims: credit loss is widespread and costly, its burden falls unevenly on financially vulnerable students, and statewide articulation policies can preserve academic standards while making transfer more predictable.
Credit Loss Is a Structural Problem
Transfer students do not lose credits because they failed to learn the material. More often, credits disappear because receiving institutions apply inconsistent rules, treat courses as electives rather than degree requirements, or fail to explain how prior coursework fits into a major. The U.S. Government Accountability Office found that students who transferred between 2004 and 2009 lost an average of 43 percent of their credits, or roughly 13 credits, about one semester of full-time study (U.S. Government Accountability Office, 2017). For students moving from public two-year to public four-year institutions, the average loss was lower but still substantial, at about 22 percent. Those figures describe more than an administrative inconvenience. A student who loses a semester of credits may need another term of tuition, housing, transportation, and forgone earnings.
Credit loss also affects degree completion. Monaghan and Attewell (2015) found that about 14 percent of community college transfer students received credit for less than 10 percent of their prior coursework, while only 58 percent transferred with 90 percent or more of their credits. Their analysis linked greater credit loss to a lower likelihood of earning a bachelor’s degree. The connection is logical: when students must retake equivalent classes, they spend financial aid and personal resources on work they have already completed. Some eventually leave before finishing because the finish line keeps moving.
The problem is not limited to older data. The U.S. Department of Education (2025) reports that roughly 40 percent of students transfer at some point, and transfer students lose more than 40 percent of accumulated credits on average. The persistence of the pattern suggests that voluntary cooperation among institutions has not solved it. Colleges may publish transfer guides, but students still face uncertainty about whether a course will count, whether it applies to a major, and whether an advisor can guarantee that outcome before enrollment. A mandate replaces that uncertainty with a baseline rule.
The Costs Fall on Students With the Least Margin
Transfer policy is often discussed as a matter of institutional autonomy. That framing overlooks who bears the consequences when institutions decline to accept credit. Low-income students, first-generation students, and students who depend on federal aid are more likely to attend community colleges and less able to absorb the cost of repeated coursework. When credits do not transfer, students may exhaust grants or loans before completing a degree, then borrow more or reduce enrollment to part-time status. Either outcome can extend time to graduation and increase the chance that a student stops out altogether.
The Association of American Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers notes that credit loss extends time to degree, raises expenses, increases debt, and lowers the likelihood of bachelor’s degree attainment; it also identifies first-generation and low-income students as especially vulnerable to these effects (American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers, 2026). Those consequences compound. A student who loses 12 credits may need an additional semester, but the real cost includes delayed entry into the workforce, lost wages, and the psychological toll of repeating material already mastered. For a student working to support a family, an extra semester is not an abstract scheduling problem.
Equity concerns make a statewide rule more persuasive than a patchwork of bilateral agreements. Individual colleges can create generous transfer partnerships, but students cannot always predict which agreements will apply to their chosen major or future institution. Boatman and Soliz (2018) found that Ohio students who completed the statewide transfer module were more likely to transfer to a four-year institution and earn an associate degree than similar students who did not. Their study also found suggestive evidence that these students transferred with more credits. Although the module did not eliminate every inefficiency, the results indicate that a common statewide structure can improve students’ ability to carry academic progress forward.
State Mandates Can Protect Standards
Critics reasonably argue that a blanket transfer mandate could force universities to accept courses that do not meet their academic expectations. A university should not award credit for a course that lacks comparable content, rigor, or alignment with degree requirements. Faculty expertise matters, particularly in technical fields where sequencing and prerequisites carry real consequences. The objection deserves a serious answer rather than dismissal.
The answer is that a mandate does not require universities to accept every course automatically. It can require acceptance of credits that meet defined conditions: regional accreditation, a grade of C or higher, and demonstrated equivalence to a lower-division requirement. Faculty review panels can determine equivalence, update course matrices, and resolve disputes before students enroll. Florida’s statewide articulation system illustrates this approach. Under Florida law, equivalent courses transfer among participating public and eligible private institutions, and the state maintains a detailed articulation manual to guide those decisions (Florida Department of Education, n.d.). The policy does not erase academic judgment; it channels that judgment into a transparent, consistent process.
Evidence from North Carolina supports the idea that structured agreements can reduce excess credit accumulation. A study of the state’s Comprehensive Articulation Agreement found that, during the first four years after implementation, students in eligible degree programs graduated with two to five fewer credits than comparable students before the policy took effect (Dadgar et al., 2021). That reduction matters because excess credits represent time, money, and effort spent beyond degree requirements. A mandate paired with faculty review therefore addresses the legitimate concern about standards while preventing institutions from using vague transfer rules to discard completed work.
The Strongest Objection, Fairly Stated
The strongest opposing argument holds that statewide mandates interfere with institutional autonomy and may lower academic quality. Universities design degree programs around specific learning outcomes, disciplinary sequences, and faculty-approved curricula. A legislature, critics argue, lacks the expertise to decide which community college course equals a university course. If the state forces acceptance of weakly aligned classes, students may reach upper-level courses unprepared, while faculty must alter expectations or add remedial instruction. In that view, protecting degree integrity requires preserving each university’s authority to evaluate incoming credit.
This concern is credible because transfer quality varies. A general education course at one college may not match the reading load, writing expectations, or laboratory experience of a comparable course elsewhere. Institutions also have legitimate reasons to require program-specific coursework, particularly in nursing, engineering, education, and other licensed professions. A policy that ignored those differences would create new problems even if it reduced credit loss.
The objection fails, however, because it treats the choice as one between automatic acceptance and institutional discretion. A well-designed mandate can do neither. It can require acceptance only for courses that faculty reviewers certify as equivalent, while allowing institutions to deny credit for courses that do not meet the standard. Florida’s articulation framework shows that statewide rules and academic review can operate together. North Carolina’s experience likewise suggests that structured agreements reduce excess credits without producing evidence that degree standards collapse. The more accurate question is not whether universities should retain academic judgment. They should. The question is whether that judgment should remain hidden behind inconsistent, institution-specific rules that penalize students after they have already done the work.
A Policy That Serves Students and Taxpayers
State governments also have a financial interest in reducing credit loss. Public universities receive state appropriations, and students often use state-funded aid alongside federal grants and loans. When a student repeats a course, public money may support instruction that has already been delivered elsewhere. Reducing duplicated coursework therefore does not merely help individual students; it makes public higher education more efficient. A student who completes a bachelor’s degree sooner enters the workforce earlier, earns sooner, and is less likely to carry avoidable debt.
A statewide mandate should include practical safeguards. States should require public institutions to publish transfer equivalency databases, give students written decisions about credit acceptance within a fixed period, and create an appeal process for disputed courses. Faculty panels should review equivalencies regularly, and institutions should distinguish between acceptance of credit and application of that credit to a specific degree requirement. These measures would make the policy enforceable rather than symbolic. They would also give students information before they enroll, when they can still choose a pathway that leads to their intended degree.
Conclusion
States should require public four-year universities to accept qualifying community college transfer credits because the current system wastes students’ time, money, and completed academic work. The evidence shows that credit loss remains widespread, that it undermines degree completion, and that its costs fall hardest on students with limited financial resources. Structured statewide policies can reduce excess credits while preserving faculty authority to evaluate course equivalence. Florida and North Carolina demonstrate that transfer rules need not sacrifice academic standards; they can make standards clearer and more consistent. For students deciding whether community college is a viable route to a bachelor’s degree, the stakes are concrete: credits should represent progress, not a gamble. A statewide mandate would make that progress count.
References
American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers. (2026). Recognition of excellence in supporting transfer student success. https://www.aacrao.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/recognition-of-transfer-student-success-v4.pdf
Boatman, A., & Soliz, A. (2018). Statewide transfer policies and community college student success. Education Finance and Policy, 13(4), 449–483. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1192642
Dadgar, M., et al. (2021). Early effects of North Carolina’s Comprehensive Articulation Agreement on credit accumulation among community college transfer students. Research in Higher Education, 62, 1–27. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-021-09626-y
Florida Department of Education. (n.d.). Statewide postsecondary articulation manual. https://www.fldoe.org/core/fileparse.php/5421/urlt/0078403-statewide-postsecondary-articulation-manual.pdf
Monaghan, D. B., & Attewell, P. (2015). The community college route to the bachelor’s degree. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 37(1), 70–91. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373714521865
U.S. Department of Education. (2025). Attaining college excellence and equity: Credit transfer playbook. https://www.ed.gov/sites/ed/files/2025-01/RTB%20Credit%20Transfer%20Playbook_v2_508_7.pdf
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2017). Higher education: Students need more information to help reduce challenges in transferring college credits (GAO-17-574). https://www.gao.gov/assets/690/686530.pdf
