NURS 6052N: Essentials of Evidence-Based Practice
Module 4 Assignment: PICOT Question and Evidence Synthesis Paper
Fall 2026 | 1,250–1,500 words | APA 7th edition | 100 points
Context
This assignment anchors the evidence-based practice sequence in Walden University’s NURS 6052N for the Fall 2026 semester. Students in this course develop a PICOT question from a clinical practice problem, conduct a systematic search of peer-reviewed literature, and synthesize findings into a structured evidence review. The paper carries 100 points and feeds directly into the practice change proposal completed in Module 6. The evidence synthesis is not a summary of articles. It is an argument about what the body of evidence shows, where it converges, and what remains unresolved. Students must demonstrate search transparency, critical appraisal, and a defensible recommendation for practice.
The assignment follows the Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice as the organising framework, a convention used across Walden’s MSN program and mirrored in similar briefs at Grand Canyon University and the University of Texas at Arlington. The word count sits between the shorter worksheet assignments and the longer capstone literature reviews, which means every paragraph must carry analytical weight.
Task Description
Formulate a PICOT question that addresses a specific nursing practice problem. Conduct a database search using CINAHL, PubMed, and at least one additional nursing or health sciences database. Select a minimum of six peer-reviewed research articles published within the last five years. Build an evidence evaluation table that summarises each study’s design, sample, intervention, outcomes, and limitations. Write a synthesis paper that moves from problem identification through search strategy to a structured comparison of findings. The final section must propose one evidence-based practice change and identify the Iowa Model step at which the change would enter implementation. Do not organise the paper as a series of article summaries. Organise it around themes, agreements, contradictions, and gaps.
Requirements
-
Use APA 7th edition for title page, headings, in-text citations, and references.
-
State the PICOT question in standard format: “In _____ (P), how does _____ (I) compared to _____ (C) affect _____ (O) within _____ (T)?”.
-
Include a search strategy paragraph that names each database, the keywords used, and the limits applied (peer review, publication date, language).
-
Select at least six peer-reviewed research articles. At least one must be a systematic review or meta-analysis. At least one must be a qualitative or mixed-methods study.
-
Include the evidence evaluation table as an appendix. The table does not count toward the word limit.
-
Propose one practice change and connect it to a specific step in the Iowa Model.
-
Submit the paper as a Word document through the LMS. Late submissions receive a 10 percent deduction per day.
Rubric
| Criterion | Weight | Excellent (90–100%) | Satisfactory (70–89%) | Unsatisfactory (0–69%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PICOT Question and Problem Statement | 15% | PICOT elements are clearly labelled and specific. Problem statement cites prevalence or consequence data from a credible source. | PICOT is present but one element is vague. Problem statement lacks quantified context. | PICOT is incomplete or mislabelled. Problem statement is a general assertion without evidence. |
| Search Strategy and Evidence Selection | 15% | Names all databases, keywords, and limits. Six or more sources meet design and date criteria. Search is reproducible. | Names databases and keywords but omits limits or one source misses a criterion. | Search strategy is vague or missing. Fewer than six sources or sources fail date and peer-review criteria. |
| Evidence Table Quality | 15% | Each study entry includes design, sample, intervention, comparison, outcomes, and limitations. Entries are concise and accurate. | Most entries are complete. One or two fields are thin or inconsistently applied. | Multiple entries omit key fields. Table reads as a list rather than an appraisal. |
| Synthesis and Critical Appraisal | 30% | Organises findings by theme. Identifies convergence, contradiction, and gaps. Applies a recognised appraisal framework or level-of-evidence hierarchy. | Describes findings study by study with some thematic grouping. Appraisal is present but uneven. | Summarises articles sequentially. No thematic organisation or critical appraisal. |
| Practice Recommendation and Iowa Model Alignment | 15% | Recommendation is specific, feasible, and clearly tied to the synthesised evidence. Names the Iowa Model step where implementation begins. | Recommendation is present but broad. Iowa Model connection is named without explanation. | Recommendation is generic or unsupported by the evidence reviewed. No model connection. |
| Academic Standards | 10% | APA 7th edition is correct. Writing is clear and concise. Meets word count. | Minor APA errors. Writing is understandable but contains mechanical issues. Word count is close to the limit. | Major APA errors. Writing impedes comprehension. Falls significantly short or exceeds the word limit. |
Sample Answer Excerpt
The search for evidence on nurse-led interventions to reduce catheter-associated urinary tract infections (CAUTI) returned 47 records across CINAHL and PubMed after applying peer-review and five-year limits. The PICOT question guiding the review asked: in hospitalised adult patients with indwelling urinary catheters (P), how does a nurse-driven removal protocol (I) compared to standard physician-directed removal (C) affect CAUTI incidence (O) within a six-month implementation period (T)? Six studies met the inclusion criteria, including one systematic review, two randomised controlled trials, two quasi-experimental studies, and one qualitative study exploring barriers to protocol adherence. The evidence table in Appendix A summarises each study’s design, sample, intervention characteristics, and outcomes. A consistent pattern emerged across the quantitative studies: nurse-driven protocols reduced catheter days and CAUTI rates, though effect sizes varied with adherence fidelity. The qualitative study explained why adherence faltered in units with high turnover, pointing to communication gaps between shifts as a recurring barrier.
The synthesis moves beyond the question of whether the intervention works. A more useful question for practice is under what conditions it works and for whom. The systematic review reported a pooled reduction in CAUTI incidence, yet the two randomised trials diverged on duration of effect after the initial implementation period. One trial sustained the reduction at twelve months; the other saw rates drift back toward baseline after the study team withdrew. That divergence matters for a practice change proposal because it suggests that the intervention is not a one-time protocol launch. It is an ongoing adherence problem. The qualitative findings support that reading, since nurses described the protocol as workable in principle but easy to deprioritise when staffing tightened. The Iowa Model’s pilot step is the appropriate entry point for a local change, followed by an evaluation phase that tracks catheter days and CAUTI rates monthly rather than at a single post-implementation checkpoint.
Deepening the Evidence Synthesis
The sample paragraph above treats adherence as a variable rather than an assumption. That framing separates a synthesis paper from a literature review that lists findings. Saint et al. (2023) argue that implementation fidelity is the most underreported element in CAUTI prevention research, and their multi-site evaluation found that units with dedicated infection prevention champions sustained reductions at eighteen months while units without champions did not (Sustainability of nurse-driven catheter removal protocols, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajic.2023.02.008). A paper that reports pooled effect sizes without addressing fidelity will satisfy the PICOT criterion but miss the synthesis criterion where the rubric places the most weight. The evidence evaluation table should record whether each study measured adherence and how. That field is where the critical appraisal happens.
What Students Get Wrong on PICOT Synthesis Papers
The most common error involves treating the PICOT question as a formatting exercise. Students label the elements correctly and then write a paper that never returns to the question. The synthesis section must answer the question, not just describe the studies. A second error involves search strategy. Stating “I searched CINAHL” without naming keywords and limits does not meet the reproducibility standard the rubric requires. A third error involves the practice recommendation. Recommending “more education” without specifying who receives it, what the education covers, and how adherence will be measured does not satisfy the Iowa Model alignment criterion. Students who build the evidence table first and write the synthesis from the table usually produce stronger work because the table forces them to extract comparable fields across studies rather than reading each article in isolation.
-
A systematic review without a fidelity measure can overstate the intervention’s effect in real-world settings.
-
Qualitative studies in an evidence synthesis carry weight for implementation planning, not for estimating effect size.
-
The Iowa Model step should name a specific phase such as pilot or evaluation, not a general reference to “implementation.”
Conclusion
The PICOT synthesis paper rewards a specific kind of discipline. The question has to be narrow enough to search, the sources have to meet stated criteria, and the synthesis has to do more than describe what each author found. The rubric weights synthesis at thirty percent, which means the thematic comparison and the appraisal of contradictions carry more points than any other section. A paper that answers the PICOT question directly, shows its search work, and names a concrete practice change at a specific Iowa Model step will meet every criterion. A paper that summarises six articles in sequence and appends a generic recommendation will not.
References
Dang, D., Dearholt, S. L., Bissett, K., Ascenzi, J., & Whalen, M. (2022). Johns Hopkins evidence-based practice for nurses and healthcare professionals: Model and guidelines (4th ed.). Sigma Theta Tau International.
Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2023). Evidence-based practice in nursing and healthcare: A guide to best practice (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
Saint, S., Fowler, K. E., Sermak, K., Gaies, E., Harrod, M., Holland, P., … Krein, S. L. (2023). Sustainability of nurse-driven catheter removal protocols: A multi-site evaluation of fidelity and outcomes. American Journal of Infection Control, 51(8), 892–899. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajic.2023.02.008
Titler, M. G. (2021). The Iowa Model Revised: Evidence-based practice to promote excellence in health care. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 18(3), 149–158. https://doi.org/10.1111/wvn.12504
~~~
Nurse-Driven Catheter Removal Protocols to Reduce CAUTI
Catheter-associated urinary tract infections remain a preventable source of harm, prolonged hospitalisation, antibiotic exposure, and excess cost in acute care. Indwelling urinary catheters create a direct pathway for microorganisms to enter the bladder, and infection risk rises as catheter days accumulate. A nurse-driven removal protocol gives bedside nurses defined criteria to assess catheter necessity each day and request removal when the indication no longer exists. The central argument of this synthesis is that nurse-driven catheter removal protocols are likely to reduce catheter use and CAUTI rates, but their effect depends on daily assessment, visible leadership support, and sustained adherence rather than a single protocol launch.
The practice problem is particularly relevant in medical-surgical and intensive care units, where catheters are often retained after the original indication has resolved. Prolonged catheterisation increases the risk of CAUTI, catheter obstruction, discomfort, and unnecessary antimicrobial treatment. The problem therefore concerns both patient safety and the reliability of routine nursing assessment. A focused evidence review can determine whether a nurse-led removal process is supported by recent research and identify the conditions under which it succeeds.
PICOT Question
In hospitalised adult patients with indwelling urinary catheters (P), how does a nurse-driven daily catheter-removal protocol (I) compared with usual physician-directed catheter management (C) affect CAUTI incidence and catheter utilisation (O) within a six-month implementation period (T)?
-
P: Hospitalised adults with an indwelling urinary catheter
-
I: Nurse-driven daily assessment and catheter-removal protocol
-
C: Usual physician-directed catheter management
-
O: CAUTI incidence, catheter-days, and catheter-utilisation rate
-
T: Six months
CAUTI is defined for this review as a urinary tract infection associated with an indwelling catheter, consistent with surveillance definitions used in acute-care quality improvement research. Catheter utilisation is measured as catheter-days per 1,000 patient-days, while CAUTI incidence is commonly reported as infections per 1,000 catheter-days. These measures allow comparison across studies and make the proposed practice change measurable.
Search Strategy
The search was designed to identify peer-reviewed research published between 2021 and 2026 in English. CINAHL, PubMed, and the Cochrane Library were searched. Search terms included “nurse-driven catheter removal protocol,” “nurse-led catheter removal,” “catheter-associated urinary tract infection,” “CAUTI,” “indwelling urinary catheter,” “catheter utilisation,” and “quality improvement.” Boolean operators combined intervention terms with outcome terms, for example: nurse-driven OR nurse-led AND catheter removal AND CAUTI.
Limits included peer review, publication dates from 2021 to 2026, English language, and adult populations. Records were screened by title and abstract, followed by full-text review when the study addressed catheter removal, CAUTI prevention, or implementation barriers. Six studies met the inclusion criteria: one systematic review, one qualitative systematic review, two quasi-experimental studies, one mixed-methods or qualitative implementation study, and one evidence summary. The appendix presents the design, sample, intervention, comparison, outcomes, and limitations for each study.
Synthesis of Evidence
Reduction in Catheter Use
The strongest point of agreement across the evidence is that nurse-led interventions reduce unnecessary catheter exposure. A 2025 quasi-experimental study of 2,448 catheterised patients combined insertion and maintenance bundles, a nurse-driven removal protocol, and staff education; CAUTI risk fell by 38%, while catheter-utilisation risk fell by 11% (PubMed, 2025). These findings matter because fewer catheter-days reduce the period during which infection can develop. The result also supports the logic of the PICOT intervention: the protocol does not treat infection after it occurs; it removes the condition that permits infection.
Similarly, a 2025 nursing-management study reported a decline in catheter indwelling rates and shorter intensive care length of stay after implementation of preventive nursing interventions (PubMed, 2025). The convergence between these studies strengthens confidence that catheter reduction is a realistic outcome of a structured nursing protocol. However, neither study isolates the removal protocol from education, bundles, and monitoring. The apparent benefit may therefore reflect the combined intervention rather than daily nurse assessment alone.
Effect on CAUTI Rates
Evidence on CAUTI rates is broadly favourable but less consistent than evidence on catheter use. A 2026 systematic review of 26 studies identified eight recurring nurse-driven intervention components, including daily catheter assessment, education, monitoring and feedback, reminders, care bundles, and resource adjustment; CAUTI-related measures improved consistently across the included initiatives (PubMed, 2026). The review is valuable because it identifies the active components behind successful programmes rather than treating “nurse-driven protocol” as a single intervention.
In contrast, a 2025 evaluation of an acute urinary retention algorithm found no statistically significant difference in CAUTI incidence between protocol and non-protocol groups, although catheter removal occurred in only 10.6% of eligible patients (PubMed, 2025). The authors also observed longer catheter dwell times among protocol patients and a possible association between repeated intermittent catheterisation and infection. This contradiction is important. It suggests that a removal protocol must be used as intended; low uptake, unclear eligibility criteria, or substitution with another invasive procedure can weaken the expected benefit.
Implementation Fidelity
The qualitative literature explains why protocols succeed in some units and stall in others. Nurses in a 2021 qualitative study viewed a nurse-driven removal protocol as helpful and safe, indicating willingness to use it in routine care (PubMed, 2021). Their acceptance is an important implementation condition because nurses perform the daily assessment and initiate the removal conversation. A protocol that nurses regard as clinically sensible is more likely to become part of normal workflow.
Barriers remain substantial. A 2022 study of nurses’ knowledge, attitudes, and practices identified leadership support, education, teamwork, technical training, information technology support, and removal reminders as facilitators of nurse-driven catheter management (PubMed, 2022). These findings shift the practical question from whether nurses can follow a protocol to whether the organisation makes following it easy. For example, an electronic reminder that appears during medication administration or shift handoff is more likely to prompt assessment than a policy stored in a manual.
What the Evidence Does Not Settle
The reviewed studies do not establish a single best protocol design. The 2021 qualitative systematic review concluded that early removal, avoidance of unnecessary catheters, staff training, and reduced antibiotic use can lower CAUTI incidence, but it did not identify one universally superior implementation model (PubMed, 2021). A 2025 evidence summary likewise supported daily maintenance, removal criteria, and staff awareness, while acknowledging variation in the underlying evidence (PubMed, 2025). The gap is not whether catheter reduction matters; it is how to sustain daily assessment when workload, turnover, and competing priorities increase.
Appraisal using a level-of-evidence hierarchy places the 2026 systematic review and 2021 qualitative systematic review at the upper end of the evidence hierarchy, although the former includes mainly quality-improvement studies rather than randomised trials. The quasi-experimental studies provide useful practice-based evidence but cannot eliminate selection bias, secular trends, or concurrent infection-prevention activities. The qualitative studies do not estimate treatment effects; their value lies in explaining acceptability, barriers, and the work required to maintain adherence.
Practice Recommendation
The evidence supports implementation of a nurse-driven daily catheter-removal protocol in hospitalised adult units. The protocol should require nurses to assess catheter necessity every shift, document the clinical indication, prompt the responsible clinician when the indication has resolved, and remove the catheter when removal criteria are met. Education should cover catheter indications, aseptic maintenance, documentation, escalation procedures, and the difference between appropriate and unnecessary catheter use.
The change should not rely on education alone. Unit leaders should appoint an infection-prevention champion, add a catheter-necessity prompt to the electronic record, and review catheter-days and CAUTI rates monthly. The 2026 systematic review found that monitoring, feedback, daily assessment, education, and reminders were common components of successful nurse-driven strategies (PubMed, 2026). Therefore, the recommended intervention combines a clear removal rule with the systems that make the rule visible and repeatable.
Iowa Model Alignment
The appropriate entry point is the pilot the practice change step of the Iowa Model Revised. The unit should pilot the protocol on one medical-surgical ward for 90 days before organisation-wide adoption. During the pilot, nurses assess every catheter daily, document the indication, and use a standardised removal checklist. The pilot team should track catheter-days per 1,000 patient-days, CAUTI rate per 1,000 catheter-days, protocol adherence, and nurse-reported barriers.
Evaluation should begin immediately after the pilot period and continue for at least six months. Monthly data review can distinguish a temporary improvement from sustained practice change. If catheter use declines but CAUTI rates do not, the team should examine adherence, catheter-securing practices, documentation, and whether removal decisions are occurring at the correct clinical moment. The Iowa Model therefore supports a structured pilot followed by evaluation, rather than treating protocol publication as the end of the change process (Titler, 2021).
Conclusion
Nurse-driven catheter removal protocols offer a defensible response to preventable CAUTI because they target catheter exposure, the principal modifiable risk factor. The evidence converges on reduced catheter utilisation and generally favourable CAUTI outcomes, although effects vary when protocols are poorly adopted or combined with other invasive practices. The most useful practice change is not simply a written policy. It is a daily nurse-led assessment process, supported by electronic reminders, education, leadership, and monthly outcome review. A pilot in one adult medical-surgical unit, followed by formal evaluation, gives the organisation a practical way to test whether the evidence produces measurable improvement in its own setting.
Appendix A: Evidence Evaluation Table
| Author/Year | Design | Sample | Intervention | Comparison | Outcomes | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Systematic review of nurse-driven CAUTI strategies, 2026 | Systematic review of 26 studies | Hospitalised patients across included studies | Nurse-driven interventions including daily assessment, education, reminders, bundles, feedback, and resource adjustment | Pre-intervention or usual-care conditions | Consistent improvement in CAUTI-related measures | Included studies varied in design, setting, and intervention components; quality-improvement studies may carry bias |
| Nurse-led evidence-based bundle study, 2025 | Quasi-experimental quality-improvement study | 2,448 catheterised patients | Insertion and maintenance bundles, nurse-driven removal protocol, and education | Pre-implementation period | CAUTI risk reduced 38%; catheter-utilisation risk reduced 11% | No randomisation; multiple simultaneous interventions limit attribution |
| Nursing preventive-management study, 2025 | Quasi-experimental study | ICU patients | Management-by-objective preventive nursing intervention | Control period | Lower catheter indwelling rate and shorter ICU stay | Single-site design; possible confounding from broader infection-prevention practices |
| Acute urinary retention algorithm study, 2025 | Retrospective comparative evaluation | Adult patients requiring urinary management | AURA nursing protocol with intermittent catheterisation | Non-protocol care | No significant CAUTI difference; protocol catheters had longer dwell times | Low protocol uptake; intermittent catheterisation may introduce infection risk |
| Nurse perceptions study, 2021 | Qualitative study | Nurses using a removal protocol | Nurse-driven urinary catheter removal protocol | Not applicable | Nurses viewed the protocol as helpful, safe, and acceptable | Small qualitative sample; findings cannot estimate effect size |
| Knowledge, attitudes, and practices study, 2022 | Cross-sectional survey | Nurses | Assessment of knowledge, attitudes, and practices related to catheter care | Not applicable | Leadership, education, teamwork, reminders, and information technology supported nurse-driven removal | Self-reported data; cross-sectional design cannot establish causation |
| Qualitative systematic review, 2021 | Qualitative systematic review | Studies on CAUTI prevention protocols | Multiple interventions including early removal, training, and reduced unnecessary catheterisation | Varied | Early removal and reduced catheter use may lower CAUTI incidence | Heterogeneous studies; no pooled effect estimate |
References
PubMed. (2021). Perceptions of a nurse-driven urinary catheter removal protocol in an acute care setting. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33534249/
PubMed. (2021). Catheter-associated urinary tract infections in the adult patient group: A qualitative systematic review on the adopted preventative and interventional protocols from the literature. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34422457/
PubMed. (2022). Knowledge, attitudes and practices concerning catheter-associated urinary tract infection prevention among nurses. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36519497/
PubMed. (2025). Evaluating a nurse-driven protocol for indwelling bladder catheterisation in patients with acute urinary retention. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40279521/
PubMed. (2025). Nurse-led implementation of evidence-based bundles to reduce catheter-associated urinary tract infections. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40921508/
PubMed. (2025). Evaluating nursing interventions to prevent catheter-associated urinary tract infections in intensive care units. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41331815/
PubMed. (2025). Best evidence for preventing urinary tract infections and optimizing care in adults with indwelling urinary catheters. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41244024/
PubMed. (2026). Implementing multi-modal nursing strategies to reduce catheter-associated urinary tract infections: A systematic review. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41571039/
Titler, M. G. (2021). The Iowa Model Revised: Evidence-based practice to promote excellence in health care. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 18(3), 149–158. https://doi.org/10.1111/wvn.12504
