Lowest price from $10 per page Start saving now →
Business Ethics

Giving Voice to Values in financial reporting

MBA402 Governance, Ethics, and Sustainability: Giving Voice to Values

Subject and Assessment Context

Kaplan Business School delivers MBA402 Governance, Ethics, and Sustainability inside its postgraduate Master of Business Administration and Master of Professional Accounting awards, and Assessment 2 in MBA402 is a Giving Voice to Values case analysis and script submitted through Turnitin in Week 8. The subject runs at the Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide and Gold Coast campuses plus online, which means several hundred students meet the same task each trimester and the case study rotates with each offering. Assessment 2 is an individual task written in three linked parts: a case analysis applying the Giving Voice to Values framework, a script in which the student speaks as the protagonist, and a reflection on the process. The design reflects the subject’s attention to how a person actually says something difficult, not merely what the correct answer is, and the framework comes from a pedagogy built for exactly that purpose.

Assessment Snapshot

Institution and faculty Kaplan Business School, Business and Management discipline, postgraduate
Subject code and name MBA402 Governance, Ethics, and Sustainability
Programme and level MBA and Master of Professional Accounting, Australian Qualifications Framework Level 9
Assessment title Assessment 2: Giving Voice to Values
Assessment type Case analysis and script, individual
Length 1,500 words, plus or minus 10 per cent, split as three sections of 500 words each
Weight 35 per cent of the subject mark, comprising 5 per cent for the workshop worksheet and 30 per cent for the analysis and script
Total marks 35 marks
Indicative timing Worksheet completed in the Week 6 workshop, written submission due Week 8
Submission Turnitin through MyKBS, single Microsoft Word document
Referencing Kaplan Harvard style, with in text citations and a reference list
Learning outcomes assessed LO1 governance responsibilities, LO2 the Australian legal and regulatory environment, LO3 the board’s role in strategy and risk

Version and Weighting Note

The weighting attached to this task has moved across offerings, so students must read the outline issued in their own subject site rather than a circulated copy. The 2025 outline prints 35 per cent, being 5 per cent for a workshop worksheet plus 30 per cent for the analysis and script, with total marks of 35 and three sections of 500 words each. The Trimester 3 2024 outline prints 40 per cent and total marks of 40, with three sections of 500 to 600 words and a discretionary note that the facilitator will stop reading after 1,800 words. A further published version prints 30 per cent with total marks of 30 and sections of 600 words. Section identities differ as well, since the 2025 outline asks the student to describe what the most difficult part of the task was and to connect the case to a personal experience, while the 2024 outline asks which was harder, the analysis or the script. Adopt the section wording from your own subject site, because a reflection that answers the previous trimester’s questions reads as recycled work even when the reflection itself is honest.

Assessment Task

Complete Part A in the Week 6 workshop and submit the worksheet no later than the end of that workshop. Complete Part B by Week 8 as a single Word document containing three sections of 500 words: a case analysis applying Giving Voice to Values, a script in which you speak as the named protagonist, and a reflection on what the exercise showed you.

Part A: Workshop Worksheet, 5 Marks

Your facilitator reads the case study aloud during the Week 6 workshop and then gives you 40 minutes of writing time to complete a worksheet on it. Submit the worksheet as directed by your facilitator, no later than the end of that workshop. Keep your worksheet, because the reflection rewards evidence that your reading of the case changed once you applied the framework, and the worksheet is the record of your first reading.

Part B: Analysis, Script and Reflection, 30 Marks

  1. Case Analysis using the Giving Voice to Values approach, 500 words. Identify the ethical issue and the dilemma facing the named character. Discuss the values at stake and the likely rationalisations of each key party. Explain how the situation affects each stakeholder and the organisation. Describe how the main character should give voice to their values, with your own reasoning for that view. Propose the actions that person should take, aligned with Giving Voice to Values principles and with their own stated values and purpose.
  2. Script Production, 500 words. Write the conversation itself, with you in the role of the key person. Sketch briefly the context, who is involved and where the discussion takes place. Give each party their own words. Articulate your values and the reasons behind your position. Voice the other parties’ rationalisations inside the dialogue, answer each of them, propose specific actions, and aim for some resolution.
  3. Reflection, 500 words. Answer the questions in your own outline. Under the 2025 wording, address the most difficult part of the task and how you worked through it, a situation in your own work or personal life where values were tested and whether Giving Voice to Values would have helped, and how the exercise has changed your thinking about ethical decision making in your current and future career.

Case Study Scenario

The authorised case study is released through MyKBS and read aloud in the Week 6 workshop, and the case rotates between offerings. The scenario below is a reconstruction written to the pattern Kaplan uses for this task, and it substitutes nothing for the released case if the two differ.

Harlow Foods Pty Ltd is an unlisted Australian manufacturer with 640 staff, two plants and an unbroken record of bank covenant compliance. Priya Raman joined as Group Financial Controller fourteen months ago. Two weeks before the 30 June year end, the Chief Financial Officer, Don Merrick, asks her to reclassify a 4.2 million dollar loan advanced to a company owned by a non executive director as a trade receivable rather than a related party loan, and to release a 900,000 dollar warranty provision he describes as conservative. Together the two adjustments lift reported profit above the interest cover covenant. Don explains that the bank is reviewing the facility in September, that the two plants run 640 jobs, and that the director in question has been on the board for eleven years and has never taken a cent he was not entitled to. He also notes that the audit committee meets in August and that Priya is the only person who has noticed. The company secretary has asked Priya, informally, whether anything needs to be flagged for the audit committee.

Requirements

Word Limits and Section Balance

  • Write 1,500 words plus or minus 10 per cent, and hold each of the three sections close to 500 words, since a lopsided submission signals that one element was rushed.
  • Declare the word count on the cover page. Kaplan may apply penalties to submissions that exceed prescribed limits.
  • Vary the section limits only where your facilitator permits, and never borrow 200 words from the analysis to pad the reflection.

Evidence and Referencing

  • Use Kaplan Harvard style for every citation and every reference list entry, since the marking guide tests referencing against KBS guidelines.
  • Support the governance and legal claims with named instruments, notably the related party disclosure requirements of AASB 124 and the directors’ duties and financial reporting obligations in the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
  • Draw on the Giving Voice to Values literature rather than on personal opinion alone, since the analysis criterion rewards showing how the framework works.
  • Keep the script free of citations in the dialogue itself, and place the scholarship in the analysis and the reflection where the reader expects it.

Academic Integrity and Conduct

  • Submit through Turnitin, since the Academic Integrity and Conduct Policy applies and the originality report is part of the record.
  • Note that the case rotates, so an answer written against a previous trimester’s protagonist will not fit the current scenario.
  • Confirm with your facilitator before reusing any part of work submitted in another subject, because the policy treats unauthorised resubmission as misconduct.

Submission Structure

  1. Cover page with subject code, subject name, assessment title, student name and number, facilitator name, due date and declared word count.
  2. Section 1, Case Analysis using the Giving Voice to Values approach.
  3. Section 2, Script Production, formatted as dialogue with speaker names and brief stage directions.
  4. Section 3, Reflection.
  5. Reference list in Kaplan Harvard style.

Marking Rubric

Criterion and marks High Distinction Distinction Credit Pass Fail
Part A workshop worksheet, 5 marks Issues identified with precision inside the 40 minute window, values named and prioritised, first reading of the case recorded honestly Accurate and complete worksheet Adequate worksheet with minor gaps Minimum requirements met, thin reasoning Absent or submitted late without approval
Case analysis using Giving Voice to Values, 11 marks Highly competent reading of both the ethical issue and the protagonist’s dilemma, stakeholder impacts weighed against one another, at least two GVV actions proposed and defended Sound understanding of the issues and the dilemma, at least two actions enabling GVV suggested Basic account of the dilemma, one or two actions proposed with limited justification Weak grasp of the dilemma, one course of action offered, gaps in stakeholder analysis Dilemma not identified, stakeholder impacts and rationalisations largely missing
Script production, 11 marks Dialogue that a real room would recognise, every rationalisation voiced by its owner and answered with evidence, clear resolution and named next steps Convincing dialogue with values stated, rationalisations addressed and actions proposed Script present and readable, values stated, counterarguments thin Script reads as narration rather than speech, rationalisations asserted rather than answered No script, or dialogue that repeats the analysis without a conversation
Reflection, 8 marks Reflects on personal implications and insights gained, shows sound grasp of the broader implications of ethical decision making, offers an imaginative account of future workplace application Sound reflection with clear personal insight and realistic future application Basic reflection on personal implications with some gaps in the wider picture Minimally satisfactory reflection, superficial treatment of stakeholder impact Descriptive summary with no personal insight
Structure, format and presentation Clear, coherent and professional throughout, even quality across sections, precise grammar and vocabulary, Harvard referencing consistent with KBS guidelines Well presented with minor lapses in referencing or mechanics Competent presentation, some referencing errors Clarity achieved only in places, referencing inconsistent Lacks clarity and coherence, grammar and vocabulary hinder comprehension

The criterion names and descriptor language above reconstruct the Kaplan marking guide for this task, which prints criteria for the case analysis, the script, the reflection and for structure, format and presentation. Printed marks in the released outlines cover the total only, so the section splits shown here are indicative. Read the operative allocation from the marking guide attached to your own subject site.

Assumptions and Verification Notes

Verified against mirrored copies of the released outlines: the subject and assessment titles, the case analysis and script format, the 1,500 word length with three 500 word sections, the Week 8 due date, the 40 minute workshop worksheet, the three learning outcomes, the Turnitin submission, and the 5 per cent worksheet component. Rotating between offerings: the weighting, which runs at 35 per cent in the 2025 outline, 40 per cent in the Trimester 3 2024 outline and 30 per cent in another published version, and the reflection questions, which changed between those versions. Reconstructed: the criterion level mark splits, since the outlines print only the total, and the case study scenario, since Kaplan releases the authorised case through MyKBS and reads it in the workshop. Do not treat the Harlow Foods scenario as the case you will be given.

Academic Integrity

Kaplan applies its Academic Integrity and Conduct Policy to every part of this submission, and the policy reaches further than copying. Submitting a script that recycles a publicly circulating answer fails on two counts here, since Turnitin matches the text and the case study rotation exposes the mismatch in protagonist, facts and figures. The reflection section is where ghostwritten work shows first, because a purchased reflection cannot describe what the writer found difficult or how their first reading changed, and markers read dozens of these each trimester. Keep the worksheet, keep draft versions, and quote your own earlier position in the reflection where it strengthens the account. Where the analysis relies on the Corporations Act or on AASB 124, cite the instrument rather than a summary site, since the marking guide tests referencing against KBS guidance and a secondary source cannot support a legal claim about a director’s duty.

References and Learning Materials

Borgen, C. and Supphellen, M. (2023) ‘Developing dynamic moral capacities in business ethics education: extending the Giving Voice to Values framework’, Journal of Business Ethics Education, 20, pp. 33-50. doi:10.5840/jbee2023204

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Available at: https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdb/au/legis/cth/consol_act/ca2001172/

Gentile, M.C. (2017) ‘Giving Voice to Values: a global partnership with UNGC PRME to transform management education’, The International Journal of Management Education, 15(2), pp. 121-125. doi:10.1016/j.ijme.2017.02.004

Kaplan Business School (2025) Academic Integrity and Conduct Policy. Sydney: Kaplan Business School. Available at: https://www.kbs.edu.au/admissions/forms-and-policies

Kaplan Business School (2025) Kaplan Harvard Referencing Guide. Sydney: Kaplan Business School. Prescribed referencing style for this subject.

Miller, W.F., Shawver, T.J. and Mintz, S.M. (2024) ‘An empirical analysis of the theoretical foundation of the Giving Voice to Values pedagogy’, Accounting Education, 33(3), pp. 319-337. doi:10.1080/09639284.2023.2185098

Zhao, H., Chen, Y. and Liu, W. (2022) ‘Socially responsible human resource management and employee moral voice: based on the self-determination theory’, Journal of Business Ethics, 183(3), pp. 929-946. doi:10.1007/s10551-022-05082-5

Note on style: Kaplan Business School prescribes Harvard, not APA and not AGLC, across its business awards. In text citations take the form (Gentile, 2017, p. 122) with a page number added for direct quotation.

Sample Answer: Case Analysis Under GVV

The dilemma in the Harlow Foods case turns on a single instruction and a long list of reasons for obeying it. Priya faces a request to reclassify a 4.2 million dollar loan to a director’s private company and to release a 900,000 dollar provision, and both adjustments together carry reported profit over the interest cover covenant. Naming the issue as a disclosure problem would understate it, since AASB 124 requires related party transactions to be disclosed and the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) attaches duties to the preparation of financial reports that a controller cannot delegate upward. The values at stake reach past honesty, because stewardship of 640 jobs and loyalty to a colleague who has behaved well for eleven years both pull in the opposite direction to transparency. Don’s rationalisations are predictable and worth setting out in his own terms: the loan is recoverable, the provision was conservative anyway, the bank will not look closely, and nobody is harmed. Priya’s task is not to win an argument about accounting policy but to make the cost of silence visible to the people who own the risk. Research on developing dynamic moral capacities in business ethics education suggests that graduates lose moral traction after they leave study unless they rehearse how they will act, which is precisely the work the analysis section must show (Borgen and Supphellen, 2023).

Sample Answer: Writing the Script

A script earns its marks in the first exchange, because the reader needs to know who is in the room and why before any values are named. Priya should be sitting with Don and the company secretary, with the audit committee deadline on the table, and the opening line should state her purpose plainly rather than hint at it. The dialogue then does what the analysis cannot, since it gives Don his reasons in his own voice and lets Priya answer them without hostility. A workable exchange opens with her conceding the covenant pressure, restates the two adjustments as the audit committee will see them, and asks Don what he would say if the bank asked directly about related party balances. Counterarguments should carry evidence: the 4.2 million sits inside a disclosure category, the warranty release reverses a position the auditors tested last year, and an unrecorded related party loan exposes the director personally as well as the company. Giving Voice to Values as a global partnership with UNGC PRME sets out the pedagogy behind this exercise, which assumes that people already know what is right and need practice at saying it (Gentile, 2017). End on a resolution with a date attached, such as a written note to the audit committee chair by Friday, because a script that finishes in agreement without a next step reads as fantasy.

Rationalisations as Predictable Scripts

Every case Kaplan sets for this task contains the same handful of excuses, and recognising them by name shortens the drafting. Denial of harm, denial of responsibility, appeals to loyalty, and the claim that the numbers are a matter of judgement all appear in the Harlow scenario, and the analysis section weakens when students paraphrase them instead of quoting the logic. Zhao, Chen and Liu found that moral voice rises when employees feel autonomously motivated rather than pressured, and that the effect strengthens where personal and organisational values align, which explains why Priya’s approach matters as much as her argument (Zhao, Chen and Liu, 2022). Research on socially responsible human resource management and employee moral voice also implies that a controller who frames the issue as a compliance demand will get less traction than one who frames it as protecting the company the CFO has spent a decade building (Zhao, Chen and Liu, 2022). Four rationalisations carry most of the weight in this scenario:

  1. The loan will be repaid, so the classification is a timing matter rather than a misstatement.
  2. The provision was conservative, so releasing it corrects an earlier error rather than creating profit.
  3. The bank reviews the facility in September, so disclosure now would be self harm.
  4. The director has behaved honourably for eleven years, so raising it insults a decent man.

Answer each with the consequence rather than the principle, since the script has 500 words and a lecture will not fit.

Reflection Marks and Common Slips

Students lose reflection marks by writing a second analysis, and the fix is to narrate a change of mind rather than restate the case. A question that circulates every trimester asks whether the reflection can describe a fictional personal experience, and the answer is no, because the criterion rewards insight into your own decision making and a fabricated example produces exactly the generic prose markers penalise. Evidence from accounting cohorts shows measurable movement in confidence and willingness to act after Giving Voice to Values cases, which gives you a defensible frame for describing your own shift rather than asserting that you learned something (Miller, Shawver and Mintz, 2024). The study of the theoretical foundation of the Giving Voice to Values pedagogy tested twelve underlying assumptions with pre and post instruments, and the confidence finding is the one worth citing when you explain what changed between your worksheet and your final script (Miller, Shawver and Mintz, 2024). Three moves lift the section:

  1. Quote your worksheet’s first reading of Don and say what you now think of it.
  2. Name the specific sentence in your script you rewrote and why it changed.
  3. One concrete situation from work or study, described in three sentences, beats a paragraph of abstraction.
  4. Close on a behaviour you will adopt, not a feeling you will carry.

Keep the reflection in first person throughout, since the criterion asks for personal implications and the passive voice hides them.

Word Budgets and Speaking Barriers

Fifteen hundred words look generous until the three sections compete for them, and the allocation should be decided before drafting. Analysis at 500 words covers roughly five elements, which leaves about 100 words per element and forbids a long introduction. The script consumes words quickly because dialogue runs shorter than prose and stage directions shorter still, so a realistic script holds two scenes rather than five. Reflection is the section students overshoot, and the cause is usually a stalled opening paragraph that repeats the case. Barriers to speaking up deserve explicit treatment in the analysis, since the criterion rewards proposing strategies to overcome them: fear of the CFO’s reference, uncertainty about whether a controller has standing with the audit committee, and the isolation of being the only person who has noticed. Pair each barrier with an enabler, such as the company secretary’s informal question, which converts private knowledge into a documented concern the moment Priya answers it in writing. Note also that Australian whistleblower protections under Part 9.4AAA of the Corporations Act give a controller disclosing misconduct to an officer or auditor a statutory footing, which changes the conversation from courage to procedure.

Closing View on the Submission

Three sections of 500 words reward planning more than polish, so settle the case analysis before writing dialogue. The analysis is where the reasoning lives, and the script is where it is tested in speech, which means a weak analysis produces a script full of speeches and no conversation. Give Don his strongest arguments, since a straw opponent makes Priya look naive. Keep the resolution concrete with a date and a named recipient, because markers read dozens of endings that fade into agreement. Cite the Corporations Act and AASB 124 where the claim is legal, keep Harvard formatting consistent with the KBS guide, and hold the worksheet alongside the draft so the reflection can quote your own first reading. Check the weighting and reflection wording in your subject site before submitting, since both have changed between offerings.

=================================================

Financial reporting dilemmas rarely announce themselves as ethical tests. They arrive as reasonable requests from senior colleagues, wrapped in the language of loyalty, timing, and commercial prudence. The Harlow Foods scenario places Priya Raman, a Group Financial Controller fourteen months into her role, inside precisely such a moment. Her CFO asks her to reclassify a $4.2 million loan to a director-owned entity as a trade receivable and to release a $900,000 warranty provision, adjustments that together lift reported profit above the interest cover covenant. This paper argues that the Giving Voice to Values framework, rather than treating the problem as a disclosure technicality, supplies Priya with a rehearsable method for protecting both the integrity of the financial report and the employment of 640 staff. The analysis that follows examines the rationalisations at play, maps stakeholder exposure, and proposes two concrete GVV actions. A script then tests those actions in dialogue, and a reflection traces how the exercise reshapes the writer’s own understanding of ethical voice.

Section 1: Case Analysis Using the Giving Voice to Values Approach

The ethical issue is not whether Priya understands the accounting treatment; it is whether she will act on that understanding when her superior has framed silence as loyalty. AASB 124 requires disclosure of transactions with related parties, and a loan to an entity controlled by a non-executive director falls squarely within that disclosure perimeter. Reclassifying the advance as a trade receivable does not eliminate the economic relationship; it conceals it. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) reinforces this point by attaching reporting obligations to the preparation of financial reports that a controller cannot dissolve by deferring to a CFO’s judgement. The dilemma, therefore, is relational rather than technical. Priya must weigh candour against affiliation, and she must do so while holding a position of comparatively limited organisational tenure.

The values at stake pull in several directions. Transparency and stewardship sit on one side, since accurate disclosure protects creditors and preserves the reliability of the covenant calculation. Loyalty sits on the other, not as a trivial instinct but as a legitimate attachment to a CFO who has spent years building the company and to a workforce whose livelihoods depend on the bank facility. GVV does not ask Priya to discard loyalty. It asks her to recognise that loyalty to the organisation’s long-term viability and loyalty to a single executive’s short-term comfort are not the same commitment. Borgen and Supphellen argue that business ethics education must develop dynamic moral capacities, meaning the ability to interpret a values conflict and adapt a response across contexts rather than merely identify the right answer. Priya’s task is to convert an abstract commitment to honesty into a workable intervention inside a specific room, with specific people, under time pressure.

Don Merrick’s rationalisations are predictable and worth naming in his own terms. He claims the loan is recoverable, so the classification is a timing matter. He claims the provision was conservative, so its release corrects an earlier error rather than manufactures profit. He claims the bank will not scrutinise the relevant balance, so disclosure now would be self-harm. He claims the director has behaved honourably for eleven years, so raising the issue insults a decent man. Gentile’s framework treats these reasons and rationalisations as the central material of ethical rehearsal, not as distractions from principle. Each rationalisation redirects attention from the consequence of the act to the character of the actor or the likelihood of detection. A GVV response must therefore answer the consequence rather than dispute the character.

Stakeholder impact sharpens the case for voice. The bank relies on covenant accuracy to price and renew the facility; misstatement exposes it to undisclosed related-party risk. The director faces personal exposure if the loan remains undisclosed, because concealment transforms a recoverable advance into a governance failure attached to his name. Employees have an interest in the facility’s renewal, but that interest is not served by a financial report that collapses under audit scrutiny. The audit committee, which meets in August, is deprived of the information it needs to discharge its oversight role. Priya herself carries professional exposure, since she is the only person who has noticed and will be the person who signed the reclassification if she complies.

Two GVV actions follow. First, Priya should answer the company secretary’s informal question in writing, converting private knowledge into a documented concern before the audit committee meets. Part 9.4AAA of the Corporations Act provides a statutory footing for disclosures of this kind to officers and auditors, which shifts the framing from personal courage to procedural protection. Second, she should request a short meeting with Don, state her position plainly, and propose a compliant alternative: disclose the loan under AASB 124 and defer the provision release until the auditors can test the warranty balance. Miller, Shawver and Mintz found that GVV cases measurably increase students’ confidence and their stated likelihood of acting when confronting an ethical conflict, which supports the pedagogical logic of rehearsing these actions before the conversation occurs. The analysis does not guarantee that Don will agree. It guarantees that Priya will not be improvising when she speaks.

Section 2: Script Production

Context: Priya Raman’s office, two days after the CFO’s initial request. Don Merrick sits across the desk. The company secretary, Helen Park, has been invited by Priya to take notes. A draft audit committee agenda sits on the table.

PRIYA: Don, thank you for coming. I asked Helen to join because I want a record of what we agree. I have looked at both adjustments, and I cannot sign the report as they stand.

DON: Priya, we have been through this. The loan is good. The director is good for it. You are treating a timing issue like a fraud.

PRIYA: I am treating it as a related-party balance. AASB 124 does not ask whether the borrower is good for the money. It asks whether the relationship is disclosed. If the bank reads a trade receivable where a director loan sits, the covenant calculation rests on a classification the auditors will challenge.

DON: The provision is conservative. Releasing it is not creating profit; it is correcting an old estimate.

PRIYA: The estimate was tested last year. Releasing it two weeks before year end, in the same adjustment that fixes the covenant, makes the motive visible even if the accounting is arguable. I am not saying you are wrong about the warranty trend. I am saying the timing turns a judgement into a signal.

DON: The bank reviews us in September. You disclose this now and we hand them a reason to tighten the facility. Six hundred and forty jobs sit on that decision.

PRIYA: I know. That is why I am not asking you to volunteer a problem. I am asking you to let the audit committee see the balance and decide how to present it. If the loan is recoverable, disclosure costs us nothing but a conversation. Concealment costs us the facility if the bank finds out later, and it costs the director personally.

DON: Eleven years on the board. Never taken a cent he was not entitled to. You want to put his name in a note?

PRIYA: I want to protect his name by keeping the transaction above board. An undisclosed related-party loan is the thing that damages him. A disclosed, performing loan is a governance footnote.

HELEN: The audit committee chair has already asked whether anything needs flagging. If Priya answers that question in writing, the committee has a record either way.

DON: (pause) I do not like it.

PRIYA: You do not have to like it. I will draft the disclosure note today. You review it before it goes to Helen. If you want the provision release reconsidered, we put it to the auditors with the warranty data and let them test it. What I will not do is sign a report that describes a director loan as a trade receivable.

DON: And if I take this to the CEO?

PRIYA: Then the CEO will have the same note, the same standard, and the same auditors. I would rather resolve it here. But I am not asking your permission to disclose a related-party balance. I am telling you what the report will say.

HELEN: I will minute that Priya has agreed to prepare a disclosure note for the audit committee, and that the provision release remains under review.

DON: (after a pause) Send me the draft before Friday.

Section 3: Reflection

The hardest part of this task was not identifying the disclosure problem. The worksheet took twenty minutes and produced a confident diagnosis: the loan was a related-party balance, the provision release was suspiciously timed, and Priya had a clear obligation to escalate. What took far longer was writing the script without turning Priya into a lecturer. My first draft had her explaining AASB 124 to a CFO who already knew the standard, which read as condescending and unrealistic. Rewriting the dialogue forced me to give Don his strongest argument, the 640 jobs, and then find a response that acknowledged the weight of that argument rather than dismissing it. The sentence I rewrote most often was Priya’s answer to the loyalty appeal. My worksheet version said loyalty to the company meant disclosure. The script version says loyalty means keeping the transaction above board so the director is protected, which is a narrower and more persuasive claim.

A situation from my own work tested a similar muscle, though on a smaller scale. In a group project, one member submitted a financial analysis with a source that did not support the figure it was attached to. Raising it felt disproportionate; the mark was not materially affected, and the member had done most of the drafting. GVV would have helped because it supplies a script for exactly that disproportion: name the consequence, propose a fix, and avoid framing the conversation as a character judgement. I said nothing at the time. The exercise has made that silence harder to justify.

What has changed in my thinking is the role of rehearsal. Ethical decision-making in a finance career will not wait for a quiet moment of reflection. It will arrive as a meeting request, a draft report, and a senior colleague who is already convinced. Miller, Shawver and Mintz show that confidence and willingness to act can be developed through structured practice, and this task demonstrated why. The behaviour I will carry forward is a written record. When an informal question arrives, I will answer it in writing. A documented concern is harder to ignore than a verbal one, and it protects the person who raised it. The point of GVV is not to win an argument. It is to make the cost of silence visible before silence becomes the default.

Conclusion

The Harlow Foods case turns on a controller who knows the right treatment but must decide whether to say it aloud to the person who signs her performance review. GVV supplies the missing middle ground between knowing and acting: a rehearsed, consequence-focused script that protects the financial report without turning a colleague into an enemy. Priya’s written note to the company secretary and her direct conversation with Don are modest actions, but they convert private knowledge into an organisational record. That record is what the audit committee needs, what the bank is entitled to rely on, and what the director himself is better served by. Ethical voice in financial reporting is not a personality trait. It is a procedure, and procedures can be practised.

Reference List

Borgen, C. and Supphellen, M. (2023) ‘Developing dynamic moral capacities in business ethics education: extending the Giving Voice to Values framework’, Journal of Business Ethics Education, 20, pp. 33–50. doi:10.5840/jbee2023204.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Available at: https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdb/au/legis/cth/consol_act/ca2001172/.

Gentile, M.C. (2017) ‘Giving Voice to Values: a global partnership with UNGC PRME to transform management education’, The International Journal of Management Education, 15(2), pp. 121–125. doi:10.1016/j.ijme.2017.02.004.

Miller, W.F., Shawver, T.J. and Mintz, S.M. (2024) ‘An empirical analysis of the theoretical foundation of the Giving Voice to Values pedagogy’, Accounting Education, 33(3), pp. 319–337. doi:10.1080/09639284.2023.2185098.

Zhao, H., Chen, Y. and Liu, W. (2022) ‘Socially responsible human resource management and employee moral voice: based on the self-determination theory’, Journal of Business Ethics, 183(3), pp. 929–946. doi:10.1007/s10551-022-05082-5.

Order a paper like this

  • High school$10/page
  • College$13/page
  • University$14/page
  • Free title page and bibliography
  • Unlimited revisions
  • Plagiarism-free guarantee
Order now See full pricing

 

 

Need a custom paper on this topic? Our experts can help.

Order now

Ready to get your paper started?

Share your instructions, pick a deadline and we will match you with a qualified writer.